I don't think it's quite that black and white.
I think there are people who like the idea, but think it's priced too high.
- Cost for this is $119, for a total of 4 hours in the park. (The regular operating hours on all of the days listed in the OP is 9am-8pm, so the event ends at 11pm according to the OP). That's more than a one day ticket costs on any of those days (each day is $105 according to TP), and those with a one day ticket are getting 11 hours in the park.
- Yes, there are other benefits, and I'm not discounting them, but the value of them will be different person-to-person.
I think there are people who don't mind the idea (don't love it, don't hate it), but don't like that its implementation is taking away park time from other guests.
- Park hours in 2016 compared to 2017 (comparing the same Thursday to the same Thursday,and based on park hours as Disney site has them listed for 2017 at the time of this post):
- January 21 2016, 9am - 8pm January 20th 2017, 9am-8pm (These are the same)
- January 28, 2016, 9am-8pm January 27th 2017, 9am-8pm (These are the same)
- February 4 2016, 9am - 9pm February 2nd 2017, 9am-8pm (Net loss of 1 park hour for general public)
- February 11 2016, 9am - 11pm February 9th 2017, 9am-8pm (Net loss of 3 hours for general public)
- February 18 2016, 9am-10pm February 16 2017, 9am-8pm (Net loss of 2 hours for general public)
- March 4 2016, 9am-9pm March 2nd 2017, 9am-8pm (Net loss of 1 hour for general public)
- March 11th 2016, 9am-11pm March 9th 2017, 9am-8pm (Net loss of 3 hours for the general public)
- Total loss of hours available to the general public over those days this year is 10 hours....almost a full day of park operations at that time of year.
- Again, I'm not saying I believe this is a *huge* deal myself, but I can see how people who might return every year around the same time might be less than thrilled at now having to pay for hours that they used to have available to them as part of the regular operating day.
I do think there are people who don't like all the upsells that Disney is doing, just flat out.
I don't think it's "hating on" Disney to dislike the upsells, though.
I also think there are those who can see and acknowledge that upsells like this may be good business sense for Disney, but just don't personally like the idea.
Basically I'm just getting at the point that I don't think it's right to just boil this down to a black and white issue like it seems the post quoted is trying to do. I think most people have a bit more thought go into their reactions than just those 2 possibilities.