Pick one please!

[maxiesmom]

We have not had a meal at any of these restaurants. Which one would you pick? Will be my sister and I, and we like both steak and seafood.

 

[Brian Noble]

I always find steakhouses to be sort of the same thing. Big hunk o meat, cooked properly.

Seafood gives the kitchen a little more latitude to try things.

 

[thanxfornoticin]

Voted Flying Fish - not the best restaurant, but the best of the 3 you asked about!

 

[gottalovepluto]

Love seeing where my opinion ranks on these types of polls- only to open this thread and realize I have been to none of these places lol. Going to follow along, time to broaden my horizon!

 

[georgina]

Love seeing where my opinion ranks on these types of polls- only to open this thread and realize I have been to none of these places lol. Going to follow along, time to broaden my horizon!

Me neither! My go-to at the Boardwalk is the Fountain or Il Mulino. I don't care much for steakhouses.

 

[Specter]

Of the 3 we have only been to Flying Fish, but we loved it. Sadly, we just don't make it to the resort restaurants at the Epcot area resorts very often but a few years ago DW and I saw the menu at Flying Fish and had to try it. Specifically it was the potato wrapped snapper which was so good.

Sadly, we have not been back and it is not on our list for our next trip, not because it wasn't great, it was one of the best Disney dining experiences we've had from the food to the service (possibly the best service we have ever had at a Disney restaurant), but that is because DD is five and a half and while she can be bougie, we just prioritize park time now and, while she's at "that" age, character meals. Those and places we can get to on the monorail have definitely taken priority the last few years but when DD is a little older we will definitely be back.

 

[maxiesmom]

Me neither! My go-to at the Boardwalk is the Fountain or Il Mulino. I don't care much for steakhouses.

We have had dinner there before and do plan on going there too.

 

[patty57]

Echoing others that a steak house is a steak house. Flying Fish is my pick.

 

[MinnieMSue]

We are at flying fish for first time and really enjoyed it. We have been trying to do new things every trip this year and it is surprising how many new things (to us) there are to do after so many trips

 

[japanese maple]

We are doing Flying Fish and Schula's this trip, so...why not both?

 

[maxiesmom]

We are doing Flying Fish and Schula's this trip, so...why not both?

Trying to not go too crazy.

 

[B-Ride]

Can't offer an opinion since we haven't eaten at any of these 3. Wait, why am I posting then?

 

[gharter]

We love Flying Fish and dine there each trip. Have not tried the other two.

 

[hertamaniac]

Did Flying Fish and Yachtsman last spring. FF was our 2nd visit and was a letdown. The fish portion size was laughable at the price point. Yachtsman was our first visit and was outstanding. The garlic served with the rolls was so good as was my prime rib.

 

[Jasper&Bowie]

I voted for Yachtsman but Flying Fish is also excellent. I have not been to Shula's.

 

[Robber Baron]

Yachtsman is off our list.

I had a great steak at Flying Fish and the entire meal was delicious and upscale.
Unfortunately FF has only one steak option.

Shula's is one of our favorite restaurants. I like the variety available at Shula's better than any other Disney Steakhouses. I *typically* avoid ordering steaks out because I can do a better job at home. But, I like the options at Shula's of a Steak Diane, or, an au poivre, or others.

I'd have to choose Shula's

 

[DizDaD7]

Yachtsman is off our list.

I had a great steak at Flying Fish and the entire meal was delicious and upscale.
Unfortunately FF has only one steak option.

Shula's is one of our favorite restaurants. I like the variety available at Shula's better than any other Disney Steakhouses. I *typically* avoid ordering steaks out because I can do a better job at home. But, I like the options at Shula's of a Steak Diane, or, an au poivre, or others.

I'd have to choose Shula's

Trying to not go too crazy.

The only reason I voted for YS is for the sole fact that I've never tried the other 2. Heard great things about them both, but still have never ventured...Now with the YS, the meal and service was fantastic...Yes a lil pricey,but in Disney standards not so much...

 

[SimplyGoofy]

I’d say Flying Fish. I’ve not been to Shula’s and really liked my meal at Yachtsman, but our meal at Flying Fish last May was excellent. My scallops were perfect and my husband loved his fish.

 

[tigerlilly]

I voted for Yachtsman as Flying Fish is literally the only restaurant I have walked out of after ordering drinks in my 55 year life lol. This was last October. I was in tears it was so bad. Seating, staff, freezing room. We were staying at BW for our big family trip. I had looked forward to this meal with my adult children for months (made those darn reservations 60 days out at 3 AM PST lol). Just a highly negative experience (this was during a massive conference at the BW which definitely impacted our experience). Joined walk up list at Yachtsman. Walked in..lovely staff, seated immediately in a lovely table by the window. Waitstaff amazing, food and wine wonderful. We had filet, sea bass, lobster bisque, wedge salad, short rib, truffle fries, mashed potatoes, mac and cheese and brussels sprouts.

All your responses make me want to give Shula's a try!

 

[Lewisc]

Flying Fish. I'd probably pick blueZoo but that's not on your list