I forced a lot of Sesame Street on my kids (especially DD18) early on just because I loved it as a young child and still have a real soft spot for it as an adult. I went as far as getting several of the Old School dvds for them just because I missed some of the older content. The older content is also pre-Elmo. That being said, neither kid had major love for Elmo. Still, Elmo is linked to many other Muppets and Sesame Street memories so I'm going to extrapolate a bit for my gratitude. The reality is that Elmo is sort of an amalgam of the best of Sesame Street's most popular characters all blended into one and aged down for younger viewers.
Cookie Monster - He was and still is DD18s Sesame Street Muppet. His over the top passion for cookies made her laugh hysterically. It started for her in mid to late infancy and it was that intoxicating unfiltered laughter you hear in babies and young children. We had so many Cookie toys, which surprisingly often came with Elmo counterparts. DD16 never latched on to any of the Muppets the same way, but she does share at least a lot of "like" for Cookie. She recently went thrifting and saw a Cookie shirt that she really liked. Her friend talked her out of it, but after hearing about it, I insisted she go back to get it if she thought she'd wear it. It's one of those spin offs from "Straight Outta Compton." It's got Cookie on the front and it says "Straight Outta Cookies!" All of the Christmas stuff is packed up until next year, but I always love when I get to DD18s Lenox Cookie Monster ornament. It just brings back so many memories.
Ernie - Ernie is and will always be my favorite. Ernie was "the" Sesame Street character, from what I understand, until Elmo came along. Elmo possesses much of Ernie's positivity and optimism, but in a more juvenile and cuddly fluffy monster package. For as much as Ernie pesters Bert, he teaches about friendship and self confidence (among other things). I'd say DD16 is more of an Ernie kid. I think it was back in her 10U or 12U softball days...we wanted to do funny walk up songs from a favorite childhood show and Rubber Duckie was hers. While we no longer do walk up songs in travel ball, high school does them and it's tradition to give the freshman that make varsity something embarrassing. I know she pushed for Ernie's Rubber Duckie to be hers last year.
Preserved Content - In the early stages, this meant albums...even though I think they were originally more one-dimensional and looked at more for additional home entertainment learning options on top of the show. I think I've shared before how we used to take the various Sesame Street albums out from our public library. Still, I think with the advent of Elmo and a growing shift in content style from around that time, there appears to have been some urgency fairly early on to ensure that legacy pieces were preserved. The push for this greatly intensified after the passing of Henson. In any event, I am grateful that I can still find classics like this one below readily available for viewing online. It's also a little extra special because about halfway through, Henson and Oz have a bit of a flub. Rather than stop and re-record, they just work through the error and it was left as is for the show. I believe this is circa 1975.