As you point out, tone cannot be discerned on a message board. Most of the time people offering their opposing opinion are not saying you are wrong or your experience didn't happen. But it sometimes feels that way, doesn't it?
Several people took Gentry2004 to task because of his experiences - even your reply to him comes off as dismissive. I'm sure it isn't but tone can't be discerned on a message board. I worry that my question to him and my reply might come off that way. I've never been able to get from plane to hotel in 45 (50 with a bathroom break) minutes when renting a car. Doesn't mean it can't happen.
I certainly don't mean to sound dismissive...far from it. BUT.....45 mins from gate (let alone plane) to resort is not routine. Have I done it in that time? Yes. But, I had a car service waiting for me at the bottom of the escalator, no checked bags. Straight to his car, and to the resort. To get from the gate to leaving the terminal, using a rental car, in 15 mins is extraordinary. And not something that happens very often. And to say that DME is a mess and not a success? Sorry, but because it didn't work for someone eight years ago does not mean it's a mess and unsuccessful today. I always try to give current, good info. Having someone say something based on an eight year old experience is not current or helpful.
However, visitors who've experienced a variety of transportation forms - such as yourself - are more entitled
And we all know mom is always right!
Yes, I've used every mode of transport to get from MCO to WDW. Sometimes I've been offered a speedier method but refused because I wanted to see what this new method offered, even if it took longer. I track my times. I take this board very seriously...and want only good, current info given. No, not every single person that uses DME, to or from the airport, is going to have a terrific experience. And we welcome those reports. Having all kinds of reports is the only way to make an informed decision regarding your transportation at WDW. But, here's the thing.....I rent a car more often than not lately. But, that's so that I can visit my dd and do stuff with her. I tend to still use the buses when I go to the parks. I find that most drivers in the area are either locals who are hell-bent on getting to their destination as quickly as possible, with little to no regard for others on the road, or tourists who have no idea where they're going and make last minute decisions. But, many others prefer to take their cars to the parks, hating the bus system. And that's fine. If it works for you, terrific. But, please, don't make those that choose a different way feel like idiots for their choices. And that's what happens here.....I take the bus, someone tells me that taking my car is a much better option and that the buses are awful! No, I don't see it that way, and no, that doesn't make me stupid.
I hope my remarks don't come across as snarky...those here that know me, realize I can be a bit on the snarky side. But, in this case, that isn't my intent. I don't want to hurt anyone's feelings. I want all to feel welcome to post here...even if they disagree with me, or others. But, if I see something that is going to lead others astray, then it will be addressed.
