I've done the Magic and the Dream, and while the classic ships have a certain intimacy that can't be matched by the newer fleet, I prefer the latter. They are a bit harder to navigate to be fair. Some random thoughts:
Animator's Palate: Agree. Not as good at the original on the Wonder and Magic. I miss that old show.
Skyline Lounge: That's where we've always had our mixology classes. Fun location, very fun class as long as the others there participate.
Meridian: Same thoughts on the martinis, though I don't mind a classic on occasion. Had different non-traditional ones than you, but my wife liked those--the classics not so much.
Match Your Mate: We got to play on our honeymoon as we were the couple who had been married the shortest amount of time (1 day). I don't know how it played out with the game you watched, but I've yet to hear or see anyone but the longest married couple win. We're outgoing and loved playing, and actually matched more answers; however, the longest-married ones made a very cute couple. At one point, I made some mildly salacious comment in regards to one of the adult-oriented questions that got the moderator and audience quite tickled. At least 2-3 times a day after that (it was the first night), someone would see us and wink and say "hey, guys!" Too funny!
Remy: You haven't gotten there yet in your report, but we've done it every cruise, and it is like a mini-version of Victoria & Albert's. We always went on the final night of the cruise until this last trip, and we opted to do it on the first night since that was our actual anniversary. Not one other soul dined there that evening. We had the entire staff and kitchen at our service. We asked why and it turns out that the first night is always the least busy since people a) want to get into the rotational dining first and b) want to save Remy for last. Usually, they have at least a few tables but not on this night. We arrived for the first seating and didn't leave until well after the last seating--no one showed.
As for the whole putting something by someone, it's tough on us guys trying to do that. I'm not personally a big planner, either, so my wife has all the details. However, I'm darn good at working behind the scenes when needed, so all kind of props to your fiance for his work to make your proposal special. Looking forward to hearing more!