See, this is a great post. I think the average FP+ hater/disliker would come up with the EXACT list of pros and cons. However, most of them see con #2 as being a MASSIVE downgrade. And all the cons are niceties that would never impact someones overall enjoyment. Perhaps some people have had their day ruined, digging through their pocket for their room key, but not me. I would, however have my day ruined if I got a very limited number of rides.
-Jason
Fair enough.
I will add this pro:
Through a combination of Rope Drop and EMH, a visitor can still maximize their ride opportunity adding in FP+ and see minimal difference under the old system. Especially if they are able to use the app to only go to standby attractions that meet their litmus for maximum wait time (ours was 30 min or less).
I posit that if a visitor was not doing RD or EMH, they likely were not seeing all if the advantages of the old system.
Without EMH and traveling with a large group, my smaller group of 8 managed: Voyage of the Little Mermaid, Goofy Barnstormer x 2, race cars x2, carouselx2, IASW, POTC, story time with Belle, HM, Peter Pan, tea cups, Buzz Lightyear, TTA, and Space mountain. Our FP+ was for PP, POTC, and space mountain with our time slots coinciding with lengthy standby waits. ETA: we also, with wait time, had 90 minutes dedicated to dinner at BOG. So pretty productive day, I think. Also forgot that we did the Electrical Parade and had lunch at Pecos Bill.
Splash mountain was closed, we had a mix if big and little. And my tall people decided to spend the last 2+ hours of park time with Sorcerors of the magic kingdom. Thus, we missed BTMR.
As you can see, we did far more than 3 rides and has several repeats. We could have hit more with the short people, but opted to just "hang out" while tall people road rides. This was a choice, but our rides would have easily been more.
In any case, as with FP- both not enforced and enforced times, users of FP+ will find ways to maximize their ride potential.
And I found our ability to maximize to be a pro for FP+ and not a detriment of losing the old system.