Disney Cruise Experts--Need Budget Advice

Whatever you do, don't even consider booking a non-DCL cruise! If DCL is your first instinct, you won't be happy on any other line.

I made the mistake of taking my first cruise on Royal Caribbean, and it almost made me never want to cruise again. I was convinced cruising was only for old, boring, chain smoking alcoholics with gambling addictions.

I'm happy I gave cruising a second chance and tried out DCL. It's AMAZING!

I can't book on opening day, personally. I just can't plan so far in advance. However, *GT rates are really good and start being released I think 2-3 months before the cruises sail. For my upcoming 7 nights on the Fantasy in a Verandah room, it was $1184 per person at the VGT rate.
 
We've sailed with our kids on three lines: Royal, Carnival, and DCL. Did they have more fun on DCL? Yes. Did they have TWICE AS MUCH fun? NO. In our opinion, it is not worth the extra cost. When we sailed, it was with a Kids' Sail Free Deal, so while it was a bit more than a comparable cruise on another line, it was still decently priced. If they offer KSF again, we might look into it. For now, we (and the kids) are happy sailing Royal and Carnival.

If you decide to go with another line, you just need to pick the right ship. On Royal, anything from Voyager class or up will have plenty for your kiddos to do (and some of the ships offer the DreamWorks characters, too). With Carnival, look for a newer ship (Dream, Magic, Breeze) or a ship with a recent refurb that includes 2.0 upgrades like the Water Park. My kids had a BLAST at the water park on the Magic in February. They also loved the ropes course. We paid $1,400 for a 7 day cruise for our family of four. We will be sailing the Allure of the Seas (I'd like to see anyone's kids TRY to get bored on that ship) over Thanksgiving. Thanks to Royal's kids' sail free deal, we paid just under $2,200 for the four of us for a 7 day on a holiday week.

I hope you look into other lines. Often times, you can take two cruises for the price of one cruise on Disney.



Our thinking was to try DCL to see if they liked cruising and then venture to the lines we have traveled. Could you PM me how you get such great rates, through the cruise line themselves? or certain website. Thanks for that info about the kids sail free, as I will be looking for those offers!
 
DCL is awesome! We are going on our second Disney cruise next month, and our eighth cruise overall. With younger children, no other line can compare to a Disney cruise. Like another poster said, it's like comparing Six Flags with WDW. Sure one is cheaper, but it's like comparing apples and oranges. They're both theme parks (or cruise ships). But that's about all they have in common. The only lines I would ever sail again are Celebrity (very awesome for adults, but not so kid oriented, so maybe when the kids are teens), and perhaps Holland America. Heck no to Norwegian and Carnival.

Tips for keeping the costs down.

1. Book early.
2. Book in the off season (May, September, early November, early December)
3. Choose your cabin wisely. If you've never cruised before, you won't know what you're missing if you don't get a balcony. Our first four cruises were outside cabins without balconies. Then we got our first balcony and have never looked back. But I would try without one first to keep the cost down. Only you know if you could tolerate and inside cabin. My sister and her family do it all the time and have no problem with it, but I could not.
4. Keep the extras at bay. Set an "extras" budget and figure out your priorities. Spa? Photo packages? Souvenirs? Specialty restaurants? Alcohol? Shore excursions? Bingo? Shore excursions were important to us before having young children, but not so much now. We might get a photo or two, but never more than that. We do Palo once per cruise, but Remy? No thank you. Spa and bingo--never.
5. A 3 or 4 day cruise might be cheaper, but when you factor in the cost of getting to the port and back, the total cost per day decreases with longer cruises. Kind of like at WDW--a 7 day trip will cost less per day than a 3 day trip.
6. Do not try to save money by skipping out on cruise insurance or tipping! Those are an absolute necessity!
 
Can you find better deals on other lines? I'm sure you can but I never have when I compare apples to apples when I can actually go on a cruise.

We are cruising on the Fantasy on January 24 for 7-nights, Eastern Caribbean itinerary. Today, you can get an ocean view veranda stateroom (category 6B) on that same cruise for $4985 and some change for two adults and two kids. Yes that is a big chunk of change.

For kicks and giggles, I looked at Royal Caribbean that same week on a similar itinerary (not the exact same but Eastern Caribbean still). For an ocean view balcony room (they have balcony rooms that aren't ocean view, but what's the point, really?) to book today it would be $4682 for the same two adults and two kids.

I'm willing to pay the $300 difference (that's only $11 per person per day) for the family atmosphere, the free soft drinks, the first run movies and the Disney brand.

I had the same experience when I was looking at booking Alaska for June 2015 instead of this cruise. Everyone came within $500 for a similar room with a similar itinerary.

But again, maybe I don't know how to shop other cruise lines and get the better deals that others have posted about.
 
Also once you're onboard, you can rebook a future cruise at 10% off then DCL gives an onboard credit of $200 of 7+ night cruises ($100 for <7 nts.)
Then our TA gives us $200 OBC per cabin as a thank you for booking with her. Once our kids got to be teens (and not so teeny) ds17's feet hang off the sofa bed bunk so for Alaska we tried getting 2 cabins: a balcony for us, then the kids across the hall in a standard inside cabin. This saved hundreds by not having all 4 of us being charged for a balcony. Plus back then Platinum members would get $350/cabin for booking onboard. Add that to the $200/cabin from our TA. Multiply x 2 cabins and we had $1100 OBC plus a $650 discount off the cruise fare. :cool1: This kind of levels the playing field when we compared to other lines.

DCL has since changed their OBC policy to $200/cabin for all past cruisers but that still got us $800 OBC + $600 discount (2 cabins) for our Med cruise. (We got 3 free flights with FF miles to make this doable & split the cost with my parents of a van/driver for private touring probably saving thousands compared to DCL's excursion prices for Italy.)

Anyway, cruises I would have never dreamed possible we did with a few creative ways to save $ once you know the system. I can't stand the thought of cruising w/o OBCs now & paying full price. Also by planning so far in advance and making DCL my every birthday & Christmas gift it's doable, not a huge amount at once.
To cover our flights to FL, we have a Southwest airlines cc and charge everything on it & pay every 2-3 days so it doesn't pile up. I also shop online through SW's shopping mall to earn more points & answer surveys on e-Rewards & e-miles for more points. For 2014 that got us 9 free one way seats/flights with 3 more booked for April.

I'm an xray tech & dh is a welder/industrial mechanic so we're not wealthy, just very determined to pay as little as possible to travel. ;)

Hope you get to try it out.:goodvibes
 
Also once you're onboard, you can rebook a future cruise at 10% off then DCL gives an onboard credit of $200 of 7+ night cruises ($100 for <7 nts.) Then our TA gives us $200 OBC per cabin as a thank you for booking with her. Once our kids got to be teens (and not so teeny) ds17's feet hang off the sofa bed bunk so for Alaska we tried getting 2 cabins: a balcony for us, then the kids across the hall in a standard inside cabin. This saved hundreds by not having all 4 of us being charged for a balcony. Plus back then Platinum members would get $350/cabin for booking onboard. Add that to the $200/cabin from our TA. Multiply x 2 cabins and we had $1100 OBC plus a $650 discount off the cruise fare. :cool1: This kind of levels the playing field when we compared to other lines. DCL has since changed their OBC policy to $200/cabin for all past cruisers but that still got us $800 OBC + $600 discount (2 cabins) for our Med cruise. (We got 3 free flights with FF miles to make this doable & split the cost with my parents of a van/driver for private touring probably saving thousands compared to DCL's excursion prices for Italy.) Anyway, cruises I would have never dreamed possible we did with a few creative ways to save $ once you know the system. I can't stand the thought of cruising w/o OBCs now & paying full price. Also by planning so far in advance and making DCL my every birthday & Christmas gift it's doable, not a huge amount at once. To cover our flights to FL, we have a Southwest airlines cc and charge everything on it & pay every 2-3 days so it doesn't pile up. I also shop online through SW's shopping mall to earn more points & answer surveys on e-Rewards & e-miles for more points. For 2014 that got us 9 free one way seats/flights with 3 more booked for April. I'm an xray tech & dh is a welder/industrial mechanic so we're not wealthy, just very determined to pay as little as possible to travel. ;) Hope you get to try it out.:goodvibes

Rebooking has gotten very restrictive. You have to sail within 18 months and there Are a lot of blackout dates:( I rebooked on my last two cruises but won't be on this one.
 
Rebooking has gotten very restrictive. You have to sail within 18 months and there Are a lot of blackout dates:( I rebooked on my last two cruises but won't be on this one.

So far their new policies haven't affected us much. Even the blackout dates are not so bad. Our kids have off Good Friday and the week after Easter. We were still able to book a 4-nt sailing the Wed after Easter, returning Sunday. We get full OBB perks and kids don't miss any school. I didn't have my heart set on any particular sailing though. Sailings that include GF/Easter may be blacked out.
 
So far their new policies haven't affected us much. Even the blackout dates are not so bad. Our kids have off Good Friday and the week after Easter. We were still able to book a 4-nt sailing the Wed after Easter, returning Sunday. We get full OBB perks and kids don't miss any school. I didn't have my heart set on any particular sailing though. Sailings that include GF/Easter may be blacked out.

It's better than nothing but worthless to me now as cruising more frequently than every other year isn't possible. Luckily I got grandfathered because my cruise the Monday after Easter is blacked out. I guess my point was there are now a lot of restrictions and it used to be much more generous so it's good to be aware of that.
 
It's better than nothing but worthless to me now as cruising more frequently than every other year isn't possible. Luckily I got grandfathered because my cruise the Monday after Easter is blacked out. I guess my point was there are now a lot of restrictions and it used to be much more generous so it's good to be aware of that.

True. What has affected us is the cost of a 7-nt cruise. We were always able to get 4 of us for around $3500 incl tax (not incl air, ins, or transfers). We are not "must have a balcony" people but it's nice to have natural light.
Lately it seems all the 7-nt sailings are around $5k so we've been doing mostly shorter cruises when I feel like I need a fix.
 
True. What has affected us is the cost of a 7-nt cruise. We were always able to get 4 of us for around $3500 incl tax (not incl air, ins, or transfers). We are not "must have a balcony" people but it's nice to have natural light. Lately it seems all the 7-nt sailings are around $5k so we've been doing mostly shorter cruises when I feel like I need a fix.

I hear you! We went Easter of 2013 for $3k (1 adult 1 child in a 7a). Easter of 2015 was 35% more:( so I booked a 4 day. Our first cruise we were fl residents and paid $3k for 4 people in a category 4. Our second cruise I paid $4k for 4 in a cat 6. I guess those days are gone.
 
We cruised quite a bit and on different lines (Carnival, Royal Caribbean, Norwegian, Princess, Celebrity, Holland America and DCL). Out of all of those lines the only one I don't think I would sail again would be Holland America only because it was a much older cliental (and I'm in my 50s).

While we enjoyed DCL, we only sailed with them once. First was due to cost. We can sail any of the other lines much less expensively. Secondly, now that we don't have young children, there really isn't a draw for us. Third, DH won't go on DCL again because they don't have a casino. He's not a heavy gambler, but when cruising he does enjoy the casino each night. That's not a priority for some people, but something he enjoys while cruising as he never goes to one otherwise.

While my children enjoyed the DCL cruise, they had just as much fun on the other lines (other than Celebrity and HAL). Carnival was actually their favorite for the kids club. We booked on newer ships and didn't have the experience with the kids club that some others have posted they had. We never lacked anything to do on any of the ships we've sailed. The newer ships definitely have more to offer than the older ones, but even on older ships we've found plenty to do.
 
Book on opening day. My four day spring break 2015 has almost doubled in price since last December.
Absolutely! Go ahead and pick your ship, and then pick your cabin. Something new folks don't always realize is that all cabins aren't equal; for example, on Royal Caribbean you can get a far-aft balcony cabin with a wider room and a double-sized balcony . . . for the same price as any other balcony cabin. But if you aren't ready on the first day the dates open up, someone else will snag that super-value cabin.

Also, keep watching your price online. If it goes down, you can call in and ask for a price drop. The rules will vary from line to line, so read and inform yourself.
Remember to look at cruising as relatively all inclusive. You won't need park tickets or food.
I don't often disagree with crisi, but I think the inclination to consider a cruise "all inclusive" is a bit misleading to first-time cruisers. In addition to your cruise ticket, here's what you'll probably spend upon:

- Transportation; we always drive, but it seems that most people fly -- if you drive, be sure to include the cost of parking your car, which is not inconsequential.
- Night-before hotel; ALWAYS arrive the night before -- too many things can happen to delay you, especially if you're flying, and this is cheap insurance to be sure you won't miss your ship.
- Excursions. These are the activities in which you'll take part during the island stops. Yes, you could just walk around and shop or hit the beach, but most people want to take part in some type of activity -- snorkeling, ATV rides, whatever.
- Tips. More and more, these are being included with your initial costs, so be sure of your cruise line's policies, but traditionally cruisers tip their servers and room stewards on the last night of the cruise -- and a week's worth of service deserves a big tip.
- Drinks. Most food on a cruise is included in the ticket . . . but most drinks cost money: Alcohol, sodas, milkshakes, premium coffee. Yes, you can do without these, but most of us won't.
- Specialty food. Lots of people splurge on the "upgraded" meals at the specialty restaurants, and they are expensive!
- Insurance. You'd be wise to buy travel insurance for a cruise. You probably don't need full coverage (for example, since we drive ourselves and always go a day ahead, we do not pay for travel interruption or luggage coverage -- if we have a travel emergency, we can probably overcome it in that extra day, and we're smart enough to hold onto our own suitcases), but we'd all be wise to buy emergency evacuation insurance. Any of us could have a medical emergency, and this insurance would pay to fly you home to an American hospital. This isn't expensive -- if you don't buy it through the cruise line.

Sure, you could cut out some of these, but you probably won't.

Note that I didn't include any shopping. If you choose to do so, you can buy LOTS of junk on a cruise: Tee shirts, spa treatments and massages, gold by the inch, perfume, Coach bags, Build-a-Bears, teeth whitening service, temporary tattoos, video games, "fine artwork" . . . and then there's the casino. I personally am VERY adept at saying, NO THANK YOU and meaning it, but judging from the crowds flocking around the day's offerings, most people don't need much convincing to buy all this junk.

Another necessity that you must consider is your paperwork. That is, the documentation that will allow you to board the ship. If you're taking a closed loop cruise (meaning you leave from an American port and return to an American port -- and I assume you are an American yourself), you can board with a CERTIFIED birth certificate and a driver's license or other state-issued ID (cruisers over 16 -- children don't need this). However, many people choose to buy a passport, which is over $100 per person.
2. Book in the off season (May, September, early November, early December)
3. Choose your cabin wisely. If you've never cruised before, you won't know what you're missing if you don't get a balcony.
October and November are our FAVORITE months to cruise! I suspect that if we tried April and May, we'd like them for the same reasons: The weather is ideal. In the islands, you can wear shorts all day but you won't sweat -- and in the evening you might want a light jacket or wrap. Additionally, as you say, you can't beat the prices.

I disagree, however, about the balcony. When our kids were younger, we found that the balcony was the cheapest way of getting extra space. The balcony allowed us a space to sit and talk after the kids were in bed, and it gave Dad a place to which he could disappear while the girls were dressing. Other people prefer to get the most space for their money (and an extra bathroom) by booking two connecting interior rooms.
We are cruising on the Fantasy on January 24 for 7-nights, Eastern Caribbean itinerary. Today, you can get an ocean view veranda stateroom (category 6B) on that same cruise for $4985 and some change for two adults and two kids. Yes that is a big chunk of change.

For kicks and giggles, I looked at Royal Caribbean that same week on a similar itinerary (not the exact same but Eastern Caribbean still). For an ocean view balcony room (they have balcony rooms that aren't ocean view, but what's the point, really?) to book today it would be $4682 for the same two adults and two kids.
Hmmm . . . that didn't sound right to me, so I checked. As of today (Saturday, October 18, 2014), Royal's prices for an Eastern sailing on January 24 are as follows:

Allure of the Seas -- new mega-ship with all amenities -- 3877/family of four

Freedom of the Seas -- ship around 10 years old but still considered prime cruising -- 1273/family of four -- okay, this was actually for January 4; it wasn't available for January 24, and since this one sounds like a great deal, I can only assume that they're sold out for January 24

Serenade of the Seas -- smaller ship that many people favor, fewer amenities -- 2823/family of four

The first cruise we took was on Disney, and we loved it; however, since then we've found that we can almost take two cruises for the price of one on another line. Disney IS a great product, but it is in no way twice as good as the others!

Things I preferred about Disney: The ships they offer for short cruises are nice, whereas the other companies tend to use their older, smaller, lower-in-amenities ships for these short cruises. They showed first-run movies in a good theater. Their private island is wonderful.

Things I prefer about other lines: They tend to have more amenities, which even my kids prefer: Water slides, climbing walls, ice skating rinks. My husband enjoys the casino.

As for the activities, yes, other lines have some activities that aren't for kids; however, it's easy enough to avoid these. And I'm sorry to say that I encountered more people with a me-first, it's-my-vacation-and-I'll-do-as-I-please, "entitled" attitude on Disney. I wonder if that has to do with them having paid the high ticket price.
 
One other $ saver is for the hotel the night before. Regardless of which port you sail out of, if you just want a clean place to sleep the night before, just Hotwire a hotel. We'd do this not only in winter months but anytime cruising.
We have in the past flown same day as departure as cruise newbies but our luggage was delayed from the airline and it was all very stressful. We met people on the ship that never did get their luggage!
Another time we flew in the day prior and still had luggage delayed & it was still stressful but at least there was time to get it all resolved and not feel like we'd be late to the ship. Also when flying same day we had to get up at 3am for such an early flight that we were all crabby & snipping at each other by dinner. Not a nice way to start a vacation. Meanwhile other guests had boarded by noon, had lunch and enjoying the ship as we were just getting there at 2pm.

Since in your OP you says "kids" as in plural, I would avoid Priceline for hotels since they only guarantee bedding for 2. It's possible to call the hotel once you know which one it is and request bedding for more but know that they don't have to. If the hotel's intent with selling on PL was to fill up some king-bedded rooms, you may be stuck with that. For that reason, as a family of 4 we stick to HW. If you are a family of 5+, you may need to 2 rooms, in which case it may be cheaper to find a hotel that has suite-type rooms that sleep 5+ such as Spring Hill Suites or Embassy Suites. One of those rooms may be cheaper than 2 HW rooms.
Even for just one night I prefer to stick with 3* and up so we don't end up some place skanky and regret not booking direct.
Many times on HW we were able to get the Hyatt right inside MCO for just $55-75/nt. It's been a while though. Lately we've been staying at WDW pre-cruise.

Oooops! Sorry, I just re-read and realized you have already cruised before so you probably already know this stuff. I'm confusing different conversations.
 
Whatever you do, don't even consider booking a non-DCL cruise! If DCL is your first instinct, you won't be happy on any other line.

I made the mistake of taking my first cruise on Royal Caribbean, and it almost made me never want to cruise again. I was convinced cruising was only for old, boring, chain smoking alcoholics with gambling addictions.

Really?! Here are some pics of the Royal Caribbean ship we will be sailing over Thanksgiving. It is definitely for old, boring, chain smoking alcoholics:
sbw_AL_1842.JPG


128.JPG


Allure%20of%20the%20Seas-1010506-M.jpg


DSCN2110.JPG


Allure-promenade-parade.jpg


I could go on, but I think you've gotten the "picture" ;) of all of the old, boring chain-smoking alcoholics that will be on board with us.
 
I've taken several Disney cruises and I don't usually spend too much once on board. I carry on a six-pack of water bottles for excursions, I drink the ship's filtered tap water otherwise. I carry on my own alcohol. I also carry a large Tervis cup with lid that I can fill at the drink station (using their cups). I don't typically get many, if any, souvenirs.

I do usually splurge on Palo once or twice (dinner and brunch) but wouldn't be sad if I didn't have the funds to do so. I also got a deck massage last cruise, so I ended up with a bill of around $150 for the cruise for two palo visits and the 30 minute massage. Worth it! ;)
 
Just last week BJ's had Disney cruises and cut throat prices. 4 days for $450! And BJ's members got up to $200 gift card depending on the amt spent on the cruise. I just looked and they still have these prices offered on their website.
 
While we're sharing pics, this is the one I remember most from our cruise to Bermuda on Explorer of the Seas. Our kids were 9 & 12. I wasn't expecting to see décor like this.
Nice, huh?

 

GET A DISNEY VACATION QUOTE

Dreams Unlimited Travel is committed to providing you with the very best vacation planning experience possible. Our Vacation Planners are experts and will share their honest advice to help you have a magical vacation.

Let us help you with your next Disney Vacation!











facebook twitter
Top