Huh. Before I say anything let me state that I'm not disagreeing or challenging your experience, KPeveler! I just want to add my own, too.
I'm also 5' tall exactly, and I've never had trouble reaching the tiller on the park-rented ECVs. And I have long legs in proportion to my height, too -- many shorter folks don't have as many issues as I do because their legs are more proportionate to the shorter height. When I sit down, I lose most of my height and from a seated position I'm closer in height to somebody who is a standing height of 4'8" to 4'10" rather than 5'. Anyway, maybe it's just a difference in arm length or in how you adjust your position when you sit in the seat of the ECV!
I can tell you that I HAVE had problems with park-rented ECVs due not to height, but to weight. You have to be 18 or over to rent one and therefore they are not made with child-sized proportions in mind. I've been over 21 for a number of years now (ahem!) but I'm a very small person. Five feet tall on a good day and my weight fluctuates between 95 and 105 lbs.
Well, one year when I was vacationing at Disney and had rented an ECV from EPCOT for the day, I found the
scooter behaving very oddly. It would sometimes just -- stop -- for no reason at all in the middle of driving it. I hadn't changed my pressure on the "gas" and the battery was fully charged so I couldn't figure out why the ECV would suddenly jerk to a halt every five minutes or so. Every time it stopped I'd have to lean forward and backward and bounce around a bit to make it go again. I exchanged my rented ECV for a different machine twice, but they all had the same issue.
Finally I mentioned it to a CM, who told me that the problem was due to the fact that I don't weigh enough! Apparently the ECVs have a safety precaution built in so that children can't use them. There needs to be 100 lbs of weight on the seat otherwise it won't move forward. I must have been right on the verge of not being heavy enough because it turned out that the ECV was stopping whenever I leaned backwards against the seat back instead of sitting absolutely straight -- my weight and center of balance would shift and the scooter would instantly stop moving. In order to make it drive properly I had to be sitting perfectly straight in the middle of the seat so that my full weight was in the center.
What a pain in the ... ! After realizing this, I just started carrying my backpack on my lap instead of placing it in the ECV basket. It weighed about five pounds and that was enough to stay comfortably over the 100 lb magic number and stop the scooter from constantly coming to an abrupt halt whenever I shifted my weight. Still, it wasn't exactly comfortable to have to hold the backpack on my lap the entire trip, let me tell you.
If you're going the ECV route, I definitely recommend renting offsite. All my issues occured with the park-rented scooters, which are not only unfriendly to smaller people, they're also generally larger machines. They're all four-wheeled and very wide, which makes them awkward to steer and they can't go around tight corners very well at all. The ECV you can rent from an offsite company is much more manueverable, usually being a three-wheeled creature with a significantly smaller turning radius and a narrower profile overall. Not to mention it's quite a bit cheaper than renting from Disney each day, AND you don't have to worry about being at the park within an hour of opening or risking the entire fleet of ECVs being gone when you arrive.
The offsite companies will drop your
ECV rental off at your hotel so it will be there waiting for you at the front desk the day you arrive, and you just leave it with Guest Services when you check out. And the scooters can go on the Disney transportation buses without any problems or extra waiting -- you don't have to call ahead for a special bus or anything.
JoMarie, if you want\need to discuss Disney With Arthritis, feel free to PM me anytime. I'm also under 30 and I've had rheumatoid arthritis since I was a young teenager. I've undergone three total joint replacement surgeries (both hips and a shoulder) and I'm currently on chemotherapy and narcotic painkillers to manage my every day life. I have been to Disney as a solo traveler every year for the past 5 years, so I'd be happy to tell you about my experiences or answer any specific questions you might be worried about!
Jenni