I did a little cost comparing this weekend and based on the menu prices of everything we ordered that was covered by the
DDP, plus tax on the TS meals we came out about $320 ahead. Since snacks and CS also have tax, the number is actually a bit more than that.
Now - would we have ordered all the same things without the DDP? Probably not. But to us, ordering milkshakes and desserts and extra snacks is part of the fun. So in the end, we feel our savings were actually nearly 50% of what we spent.
One thought we had a lot on this trip, and the heat probably had a lot to do with it: We would be completely slaughtered by the Deluxe plan. We had one day where we each had a breakfast credit used (TS), a lunch credit (CS) and dinner (TS). This was Mother's Day at Boma, Pepper Market and then the Wave (where I did have an appetizer). And even then, we didn't use 6 snack credits that day. We just weren't that hungry. I'm not saying we'd never use it - DH and I have talked about a trip with just the two of us where we go to a lot of the 2TS places - because the challenge sounds like a lot of fun. But on this trip, we would have been very full and very unhappy on DxDDP.
On the other hand, we found that sometimes we really didn't want to do a TS meal. And none of the TS's really stood out to me this trip. DH and DS really like The Wave and I did enjoy it. But some of my favorites (Boma, Spoodles, Whispering Canyon) just didn't live up to my previous experiences. And we changed a lot of things on the fly (which I loved being able to do). And we had some really fantastic offsite meals. So that said, we're doing a split stay on out next trip, and we're thinking about doing the QSP for the first stay, going offsite for a few and paying OOP for Thanksgiving dinner. But who knows? In the end, I was much happier having that Key to the World card in my pocket with the room charging and DDP than not. And for whatever it's worth, I do love the DDP.
So...favorites:
DH:
breakfast: Kona Cafe - macadamia pineapple pancakes
lunch: Flame Tree BBQ
dinner: The Wave
favorite meal: Bubbalou's BBQ
least favorite meal: Boma dinner
must do next time: Dole Whip - he's missed it the last two trips!
DS:
breakfast: Kona Cafe
lunch: The Plaza
dinner: The Wave
snack: Mickey Cookies and Cream ice cream sandwich
favorite meal: couldn't pick a favorite
least favorite meal: Pepper Market
must do next time: Le Cellier (pretzel bread)
Me:
breakfast: Kona Cafe
lunch: Tangerine Cafe
dinner: Cape May Cafe
favorite meal: my pasta at Macaroni Grill
least favorite meal: Yak and Yeti CS lunch - ick!
must do next time: cappuccino float at MK