I'd personally wait for resale if it works for you. Since you already have the blue card, you're not really going to lose out by going resale.
This is coming from the one who stalked the resale page sites until I found a $64 pp/150 point contract at OKW for almost 6 months.
We did it the first round and we'll be there for the next Friday's.
Attractions available during Disney After Hours
Astro Orbiter
Barnstormer
Big Thunder Mountain Railroad
Buzz Lightyear Space Ranger Spin
Country Bear Jamboree
Dumbo the Flying Elephant
Haunted Mansion
It’s A Small World
Mad...
It really depends too on what her definition of spicy is. There's hot pepper spicy and well, spice spicy. It helps if you can choose a place to eat, go over the menu, and talk to the chef about what you're looking for.
What kind of experiences do you like? I believe that's the deluxe dining plan, not the regular.
My suggestion would be to go through the menus of the different restaurants and find something that you two would like.