We have done CC two times. Once with cabana and once without. The first time we went on the family beach and had no trouble getting chairs. Our issue was that our 18-month old was still taking two naps. After being on the island a short while, he was especially cranky and I needed to go back to the ship with him and then our family was split up. We didn't spend much time there.
Fast forward to this past January (now 3 kids - 18m, 3 and 5) and we had cabana 4. It was the best family day our family has ever had. It was literally magical in every way (and it was even raining the first hour). The best part was that our 18-month old took a nap in the cabana and everyone else could continue on with playing etc. We got our food and carried it back to the cabana and ate in our own little zone. We had a place to drop all of our stuff with out feeling like someone had to carry it or guard it all day. We had a huge section of beach all to ourselves and reserved chairs and floats right in front of the cabana. I think for us with the age of our kids and needing naps, it was well worth it.
Fast forward to this past January (now 3 kids - 18m, 3 and 5) and we had cabana 4. It was the best family day our family has ever had. It was literally magical in every way (and it was even raining the first hour). The best part was that our 18-month old took a nap in the cabana and everyone else could continue on with playing etc. We got our food and carried it back to the cabana and ate in our own little zone. We had a place to drop all of our stuff with out feeling like someone had to carry it or guard it all day. We had a huge section of beach all to ourselves and reserved chairs and floats right in front of the cabana. I think for us with the age of our kids and needing naps, it was well worth it.