We are back and ate at Toothsome's on Thursday Aug 25. We really liked it and the family (husband, teens 19, 16 and 14-all close to 6ft or over) thought it was our best meal. we did stay offsite most all our days and ate in both the parks and offsite. My middle son asked to go back multiple times.
We thought the decor was great, although my steampunk loving son thought they should have gone farther, bigger hats, etc. Kids don't notice service but my husband and I do and we thought it very good. We are not fancy people so I think this type of place suited us.
We arrived at 3:45 because I had heard they were seating at 4. When we got there they added our names to the seating list. The place seemed very crowded but I guess everyone was just looking around or maybe getting milkshakes. We were number 5 on the list (I asked because husband is not very patient) At 3:58 I got a text our table was ready, we were the second group seated (hungry kids were near the desk)
Our server Emily handed us the huge menus (large book size) and asked if we had been in the parks, said of course you'll want lots of water. She and the other staff kept those water glasses filled. When she came back to get our order she told us no milkshakes in the dining room. A bummer but the kids decided dessert instead. They did have a big sign out front about soft opening and everything not being available. She said be glad because we would have waited about 45 min for the milkshakes.
We ordered 2 warm chocolate almond breads to start (5.90 for 2) and husband got a chocolate stout (8.25) The bread was not warm, and honestly tasted like day old. You NEEDED the sweet from the caramel butter but the butter was rock hard. I suppose it was not as expected. Husband thought beer okay but he said it was fine, he is just not a fan of stout but he wanted to try it. He could taste chocolate and thought if you liked stout you would like it. We are not big drinkers though, so take that as you will.
For our meals we ordered Cheddar bacon Burger with Kettle Chips (14.95), Pub It Up Burger with chips (13.95, Four cheese Flat bread (12.95), Quiche Lorraine and house salad (10.95), and Broccoli and Cheddar Quiche and Broccoli and cheddar soup (10.95) My boys thought these were the best burgers and the chips were excellent. We are pretty sure the pub it up burger came incorrect. He special ordered it to hold the queso and dijon and it came w/o that and w/o veggie toppings but with chips on top instead. Still, he thought it was excellent and wouldn't wait to eat it til we could get it fixed. Both burgers came fixed to order (medium and medium well) and I thought them large. The flatbread was cracker thin with cheese (maybe soft goat cheese?). My daughter did not like it but everyone else did. She is very picky though and I had tried to talk her into a plain waffle. Both quiches and soup and salad were very good. Quiche also came with fruit which was some berries in some kind of syrup. Very good. The lorraine wedge was quite a bit bigger that the broccoli one. Immediately noticeable. I had the lorraine and the crust edge was really hard, although the rest was very good. Salad was fresh, mixed greens, about a cup maybe and soup was about a cup as well. Husband and I were both full, too full for dessert.
Teens always have room though and they all ordered sundaes. I had expected a regular size sundae, so we even let our diabetic son order one. He is 6'5" and can eat a lot but he still has to be careful. 2 Chocolate Brownie Bark Sundaes (9.50 each) and a Salted caramel Flan Sundae (9.50) One chocolate sundae ordered w/o whipped cream and w/o extra chocolate sauce. The sundaes came in serving bowls. Like Corelle serving bowls. I tried the ice cream and it was good, creamy. The oldest had the flan and he was able to finish his ice cream and flan. He did say the flan was cake like, so not sure about that. Came with huge pieces of almond bark, so thick he only ate part of one. Brownie bark ones were enjoyed but neither could come near to finishing them. I would say they all had 3-4 large scoops of ice cream and 4-5 pieces of brownie or candy. Could have been shared for sure.
Our total after preferred discount was 105.26 (before tip) Everyone working was super nice. Jacques came by the table which was super fun.
Sorry this was so long but I got so much help here I wanted to return a little. We found Toothsome's a great meal and value. (even with the mistakes) Our family's meal at the Three Broomsticks was 83.58 for example. The food was good but that was 5 meals and drinks (and I asked for a courtesy water-what a joke) We also had to wait forever in line there