First I will say that we have never been to DW with a party of five so we have never needed two rooms or budgeted food for 5. If you think the money is better saved for room and food costs, I'd choose All Star. But if all things being equal, I'd 100% choose Pop for the Skyliner. We loved Pop before the Skyliner and even more now. The line moves very fast, even after fireworks at Epcot.