Ahhh we love the Biergarten too. It's one of our world showcase favorites. You'll like Shula's. And it's only slightly more than Le Cellier. The steaks are better. The tables aren't so close together, and it's not as noisy. Much better for couples night out. Oh and don't bother with some of the cheaper entrees like chicken or the like just to save money. Spend the extra $15 bucks and get a good steak. That's what you're there for.
But at the end of the day it is a lot about price and bang for your buck. The same meal that is a steal at 1 credit (which Le Cellier was in he early days of he plan) may not be worth the $70 out of pocket or two credits. Plus, when it becomes a two credit place, it's going to be rated against other two credit places or other things in its out of pocket range.
Back in the early iterations of the plan you got App entree, desert, tax, and tip. So here's this place called Le Cellier and the price is fairly high and poof, you can run it up for one credit. But even back then we felt that what we got wasn't worth it if we had to pay out of pocket. But it was definitely worth 1 credit. Another place that was a DDP 1 credit wonder was Spoodles. You could really run it up there because they let you have add on shrimp skewer and an add on scallop skewer on the plan!!!!! I rang up something like $110 on one credit. HAHAHA. Now. I'd have never done that if I was paying for it with cash. But we thought Spoodles more than worth a credit. Sadly, it's gone now. We still feel that Le Cellier isn't worth the out of pocket price and now that it is a two bagger on the DDP and the DDP is a bit less generous, it's just not worth that either. There are better places for two credits on property.