November we went to Grand Cayman and tried the new Hotel Indigo that opened next to the Kimpton Seafire. We knew in booking it that we'd always go back to the Seafire, it was a more, check it out for family/friends type deal. And while the hotel was beautiful and the suite they upgraded us to was lovely, and the f&b was actually quite good, we found it boring compared to the Seafire next door. But it's nice to have more f&b options close by. So if you haven't stayed at the Seafire, honestly, I would book it on points soon, because I think it's a steal that will increase in cost and I think it's only a matter of time. The Hotel Indigo and Seafire are now at the same pricepoint, so I think the Kimpton will increase in price. Since you can buy points often at .005 and cardholders get the fourth night free, you're essentially paying $263/nt + $80/nt resort fee. It's a comparative steal to anything comparable.
We are headed to Seafire in February (first time!). I've budgeted a nice amount for F&B, but honestly we aren't foodies and I feel like splurging at the finer restaurants that are already more expensive (due to location) might just be dumb. Does the Hotel Indigo have some more casual dining that we could mix in with Coccoloba. We really just want to get to a warmer place, read some books, swim a bit and just relax. We weren't planning on renting a car, so is there a store that's walkable/bike able to pick up some snacks/drinks for the room?