I do think that how many on Disboards feel about missing Castaway is not going to mimic the same level of disappointment a new
DCL cruiser might feel who has saved for years to sail and might not be able to return. A lot of us can shrug and say it sucks, but for many of us we have been able to experience it and will have opportunities to return- this is not true across the board and I would never begrudge a guest for being upset about it as long as they don't take it out on the crew.