• Controversial Topics
    Several months ago, I added a private sub-forum to allow members to discuss these topics without fear of infractions or banning. It's opt-in, opt-out. Corey Click Here

CARNIVAL VS DCL: The discussion and comparison thread!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hope you all don't mind me jumping on here, sorry but I haven't read all 167 pages, so I apologize if some of my questions have already been answered. Little background on my family, there's just 3 of us, My dh, our 10 yr old dd and myself. We've done 5 DCL cruises so far. 1 Alaskan, 1 WC, and 3EC(all to different islands). Dh and I did our honeymoon on the Magic in 2001 and sadly haven't been back on her, although I really want to go on her again. We've been on the Fantasy twice(have another WC booked for 2020 on her) and have been on the Wonder twice. We only cruise Jan-March and only do 7nights, this is why we haven't been on the Dream and haven't been on the Magic again since they don't do 7nights in the winter. Both of our Fantasy cruises were SW themed ones, so is our 2020 cruise. My dd and I aren't SW fans, my dh likes the movies. I was so excited for our first cruise on the Fantasy, but after our last one, this past January I'm already feeling kinda blah about our 2020 cruise. I don't care for the shows on the Fantasy, and like many others, I feel like the food isn't as good as it once was. I enjoy the Anyone Can Cook demos, but they really need to change what they are doing. They've done the same foods for the past 5 yrs. My dd is 10 yrs old. She no longer cares for any of the characters, I admit this makes me happy. We no longer have to plan our activities around character meets!! She still enjoys going to the Oceaneer's club, however I noticed she started to spend less time at it on our last cruise. I'm hoping she likes Edge, when we go on our next cruise. We've never let her do self-check out and I admit, it makes me nervous that she'll be able to do it at the Edge. I've looked at the RC site to see what kind of cruises they do Jan-March. The only ones that popped up were ones for their new really large ships. I'm not interested in going on one of those. My dd isn't afraid of anything and would love all the zip-lines, rock walls, etc. I would prefer a ship the size of the Fantasy or smaller with maybe just one of those things. Not sure if such a ship exists. I haven't looked at other lines websites yet, but am interested in them. I feel a little overwhelmed by all the different ships and don't know what all the different classes are for each one.
My main question for right now is, how do you know if one of the ships on Carnival is one of their newer ships? Thanks, I have more questions, but just realized I need to start dinner.
 
My main question for right now is, how do you know if one of the ships on Carnival is one of their newer ships? Thanks, I have more questions, but just realized I need to start dinner.

Hello and welcome. The easiest way to see the newer ships is on the Carnival website/ select Explore/ Our Ships. The ships are listed from most recent build to oldest (Mardi Gras to Fantasy). The Breeze and Vista are favorites of many on this board I believe (myself included).
 
Hope you all don't mind me jumping on here, sorry but I haven't read all 167 pages, so I apologize if some of my questions have already been answered. Little background on my family, there's just 3 of us, My dh, our 10 yr old dd and myself. We've done 5 DCL cruises so far. 1 Alaskan, 1 WC, and 3EC(all to different islands). Dh and I did our honeymoon on the Magic in 2001 and sadly haven't been back on her, although I really want to go on her again. We've been on the Fantasy twice(have another WC booked for 2020 on her) and have been on the Wonder twice. We only cruise Jan-March and only do 7nights, this is why we haven't been on the Dream and haven't been on the Magic again since they don't do 7nights in the winter. Both of our Fantasy cruises were SW themed ones, so is our 2020 cruise. My dd and I aren't SW fans, my dh likes the movies. I was so excited for our first cruise on the Fantasy, but after our last one, this past January I'm already feeling kinda blah about our 2020 cruise. I don't care for the shows on the Fantasy, and like many others, I feel like the food isn't as good as it once was. I enjoy the Anyone Can Cook demos, but they really need to change what they are doing. They've done the same foods for the past 5 yrs. My dd is 10 yrs old. She no longer cares for any of the characters, I admit this makes me happy. We no longer have to plan our activities around character meets!! She still enjoys going to the Oceaneer's club, however I noticed she started to spend less time at it on our last cruise. I'm hoping she likes Edge, when we go on our next cruise. We've never let her do self-check out and I admit, it makes me nervous that she'll be able to do it at the Edge. I've looked at the RC site to see what kind of cruises they do Jan-March. The only ones that popped up were ones for their new really large ships. I'm not interested in going on one of those. My dd isn't afraid of anything and would love all the zip-lines, rock walls, etc. I would prefer a ship the size of the Fantasy or smaller with maybe just one of those things. Not sure if such a ship exists. I haven't looked at other lines websites yet, but am interested in them. I feel a little overwhelmed by all the different ships and don't know what all the different classes are for each one.
My main question for right now is, how do you know if one of the ships on Carnival is one of their newer ships? Thanks, I have more questions, but just realized I need to start dinner.

Hard to tell... I guess we just pay attention when new ships enter in service. :)

You might want to look up: Carnival Vista (2016), Horizon (2018), Panorama (2019) and Mardi Gras (2020)

Those are the most recent ships and I feel like they are becoming strong contenders in the market. :)
 
Last edited:


Hello and welcome. The easiest way to see the newer ships is on the Carnival website/ select Explore/ Our Ships. The ships are listed from most recent build to oldest (Mardi Gras to Fantasy). The Breeze and Vista are favorites of many on this board I believe (myself included).
One other note on that. The Sunshine was completely gutted and re-branded (it used to be the Destiny, I think) and has a lot more of the stuff that the newer ships have. I think they are doing that to the soon to come out Sunrise as well...

We sailed the Sunshine and really enjoyed it.
 
I haven't looked at other lines websites yet, but am interested in them. I feel a little overwhelmed by all the different ships and don't know what all the different classes are for each one.
My main question for right now is, how do you know if one of the ships on Carnival is one of their newer ships? Thanks, I have more questions, but just realized I need to start dinner.

This is a little out of date (Horizon is out and not on here, Panorama and Mardi Gras are coming soon) but it might help with sizes. Triumph is being "sunshined" and turned into the Sunrise this year, Victory will become Radiance in a similar manner next year.

I'd recommend Dream class, Sunshine or Vista class, or Panorama if you want to cruise on the West Coast, Mardi Gras if you can wait :)

carnival-ship-classes.png
 


The Grand Turk beach area by the dock has drastically changed since a hurricane. We went many years ago and there was so much room on the beach. Now its jam packed with chairs/umbrellas. You can't even see the beach. A lot of people just walk past that area and head to Jack's Shack. Last trip we rented a scooter (ended up with an ATV) and drove around island to the light house and then stopped at Pillroy beach and govenors beach. On our original trip we hung out at the beach by the ship. We also walked the opposite direction and checked out the conch shell graveyard
 
We went to Grand Turk in 2015 and it was nice, it was crowded because we were the second ship to arrive so all the spots were taken. We go again next year and I'm not that excited about it. I think we'll be the only ship in port, but with all the local vendors taking over the beach in front of the free chairs it looks hard to get a free spot where I can see the water. I'm not sure what we'll do this time, I have a year to decide I guess so time to think it over. We are also only in port a short time, but it's our second port (after Half Moon Cay which I am excited for) and I know we'll be needing some beach time! We may walk down to Jack's or do a beach excursion through the ship to get more space and less crowding. In theory any way. Since I travel with kiddo I'm not that comfortable renting anything to drive myself.
 
Thanks for the info about some of the different ships. So many different names, we wouldn't go on one until 2021, so at least I have time to learn about them all. As a 50 yr old I grew up loving the Love Boat. Spent every Sat. night watching it followed by Fantasy Island. I'd book a Princess cruise just so I could hear the song!!
If Princess were smart, they'd ditch the "Princess Cays" label, invest some $ make the place look like Fantasy Island and call it Fantasy Island.

I was told by a crewmember (so take it for what it is worth) that some of the show's regulars frequently cruise the line and that the ship allows them to do special things (like let Ted Lange mix drinks - he DID do a training video for them:) ) BTW, Ted Lange is the only "crew member" that is allowed to wear a red jacket...

 
Hope you all don't mind me jumping on here, sorry but I haven't read all 167 pages, so I apologize if some of my questions have already been answered. Little background on my family, there's just 3 of us, My dh, our 10 yr old dd and myself. We've done 5 DCL cruises so far. 1 Alaskan, 1 WC, and 3EC(all to different islands). Dh and I did our honeymoon on the Magic in 2001 and sadly haven't been back on her, although I really want to go on her again. We've been on the Fantasy twice(have another WC booked for 2020 on her) and have been on the Wonder twice. We only cruise Jan-March and only do 7nights, this is why we haven't been on the Dream and haven't been on the Magic again since they don't do 7nights in the winter. Both of our Fantasy cruises were SW themed ones, so is our 2020 cruise. My dd and I aren't SW fans, my dh likes the movies. I was so excited for our first cruise on the Fantasy, but after our last one, this past January I'm already feeling kinda blah about our 2020 cruise. I don't care for the shows on the Fantasy, and like many others, I feel like the food isn't as good as it once was. I enjoy the Anyone Can Cook demos, but they really need to change what they are doing. They've done the same foods for the past 5 yrs. My dd is 10 yrs old. She no longer cares for any of the characters, I admit this makes me happy. We no longer have to plan our activities around character meets!! She still enjoys going to the Oceaneer's club, however I noticed she started to spend less time at it on our last cruise. I'm hoping she likes Edge, when we go on our next cruise. We've never let her do self-check out and I admit, it makes me nervous that she'll be able to do it at the Edge. I've looked at the RC site to see what kind of cruises they do Jan-March. The only ones that popped up were ones for their new really large ships. I'm not interested in going on one of those. My dd isn't afraid of anything and would love all the zip-lines, rock walls, etc. I would prefer a ship the size of the Fantasy or smaller with maybe just one of those things. Not sure if such a ship exists. I haven't looked at other lines websites yet, but am interested in them. I feel a little overwhelmed by all the different ships and don't know what all the different classes are for each one.
My main question for right now is, how do you know if one of the ships on Carnival is one of their newer ships? Thanks, I have more questions, but just realized I need to start dinner.
If you’re not opposed to cruising out of Galveston, I would recommend Liberty of the Seas or Carnival Vista. Both are 7 night itineraries and both ships are similar in size to Disneyland Fantasy. If you’re open to an 8 night itinerary, the 8 night on Carnival Horizon out of Miami is an amazing cruise. We did that itinerary on Vista in 2017 and it’s been my favorite cruise out of our 6 on Disney and 3 on Carnival.
 
If you’re not opposed to cruising out of Galveston, I would recommend Liberty of the Seas or Carnival Vista. Both are 7 night itineraries and both ships are similar in size to Disneyland Fantasy. If you’re open to an 8 night itinerary, the 8 night on Carnival Horizon out of Miami is an amazing cruise. We did that itinerary on Vista in 2017 and it’s been my favorite cruise out of our 6 on Disney and 3 on Carnival.

We’re strongly considering that 8 night Southern Caribbean on the Horizon in February 2020. The itinerary looks great and we haven’t done a “new” ship on any line yet. Glad to hear you enjoyed it so much!
 
Regal Princess Review (Part 2)

LoveBoat.JPG

The Ship

Regal Princess is a big ship. Yes, she's not quite as large as the Oasis class, but she and her sister ship, Royal Princess, are the 10th and 11th largest cruise ships in the world. She's still a big ship. However, she doesn't feel like a big ship. I don't think that I ever went anywhere on the ship where it felt crowded. Princess ships have an elegance about them. They have more of a "teak and brass" feel than some of the other lines. It carries 3,560 passengers on 142,700 Gross Tons. For comparison, Disney Fantasy and Carnival Breeze are around 130,000 Gross Tons and Oasis of the Seas is 225,000 Gross Tons.

Regal Princess is centered around "The Piazza", where many of the shops, casino, and entertainment venues were located around. It was always lively and it seemed as though something was always going on here. On different occasions, we saw game shows, line dancing lessons, string quartets, party bands (including a Beatles cover band - they were pretty good!), and a whole lot of other stuff.

Atrium.JPG

Line Dancing in the Piazza

LineDancing.JPG

The ship has a pretty traditional layout. There is not a full promenade deck like on the Grand Class ships, but there are a number of outside deck areas on the promenade deck. As mentioned before, the ship has a nice wood and brass feel. It definitely feels more upscale than it's corporate cousin, Carnival, and IMHO, than RCCL. DCL fans that appreciate "the beauty of the ship", I think would feel at home on this ship. One really nice touch that I liked was that all of the stateroom hallways contained photos submitted by past passengers with photos from their trips. It would have the picture, then underneath that the person's name that took it and underneath that, the name of the Princess ship they were sailing. You can see the photos along the wall in hallway picture below. I found myself going down some hallways for no other reasons than to look at the pictures...

Hallway.JPG

There are a number of bars and restaurants as well as entertainment areas I'll discuss below. There was also a wedding chapel and a concierge lounge. One nice addition was the library on the promenade deck. It was filled with not only books, but with shelves and shelves of puzzles and games (Backgammon, Monopoly, Rummikub, Jenga, Cards, Scrabble, and on and on). This was a small area, but there was usually a number of people in here.

Library.JPG

Stairwell

Stairwell.JPG

Symphony Dining Room

DiningRoom.JPG

Lotus Spa

Spa.JPG

Pool Deck

PoolDeck.JPG

Smoke Free Nights in the Casino!!!

SmokeFree.JPG

 
The Food

So, one area where this ship really excelled was in it's food service. Unlike many mainline ships today, there are only 2 upcharge restaurants on the Regal Princess, being the Crown Grill (Steakhouse) and Sabatini's (an Italian place) and a for pay Gelato stand that was hardly ever used. We didn't eat at either during our cruise. One of the reasons we like Princess (and DCL, for that matter, and really CCL, though they have more pay places, they still have a bunch of free ones) is that the included food options are diverse and satisfactory. On the pool deck, there is the Trident Grill and Prego Pizza (pretty standard poolside cruise fare). Trident Grill would also have extra things like cheese fries, or wings, or BBQ on some nights in addition to the regular menu. There was also an included soft serve ice cream place by the pool. This stayed busy, unlike the Gelato stand off of the Piazza. Also on the Piazza is the International Cafe, which while being the main espresso coffee bar also is a 24/7 sandwich/soup/bistro/pastry kind of place. The food is all included, our go-to being the ever available ham and cheese croissant. Also of note, they always had 4 different kinds of cookies here (double chocolate being my favorite).

Another nice option is that on the 2nd sea day, Princess offers a pub lunch in the Crown Grill that is complimentary. This stayed busy and was really good.

PubLunch.JPG

A quick aside. My wife is Elite with Princess. Part of this means that by default, they put a minibar setup in our room. As neither of us are big drinkers, one of the nice things you can do is swap it out for other options, one of which is a 15-count Premium Coffee package for 2 people in the stateroom. So, DW and I had basically free specialty coffee drinks all week (Caramel Latte for me and Salted Caramel Latte for DW) and had plenty left to get DD and her friend Caramel Frappucinos a few times...

IC.JPG

Another included option is the dedicated pizzeria, Alfredo's, off of the Piazza. This place was table service individual pizzas, pastas, and calzones. DD and her friend LOVED this place. They literally wanted to eat here every night. Pizzas were fantastic (they were good on deck too, but these are another level)

Alfredos1.JPG


Alfredos2.JPG

Alfredos3.JPG

Alfredos4.JPG

The MDR was very good as well, but we only went 3 nights. One night we went to Alfredo's and the other 3, we ate at the buffet, which brings me to: The Buffet.

Now, I am not usually a big fan of buffets. Cabanas is fine, but it's not the number one thing I think about on a DCL cruise. Carnival's buffets are "good" as well, but I don't remember much about it. RCCL's Windjammer (at least on the Serenade) was mediocre at best. On Princess, I had mixed experiences. Our first cruise on the Dawn Princess was great. The rest were in the fine, but don't remember much, and last summer, we sailed Emerald Princess to Alaska and it was downright not good (which surprised us). So, we didn't have big expectations going in. I had read that the buffet on the Royal class ships was better, but we were in for a very pleasant surprise when we got on board. Quite honestly, Regal Princess has the best buffet of any of the 23 cruises I've been on, and, it's not even close!

The buffet is huge. There are literally 3 different buffet areas as well as a 4th area that was dedicated to pastries and desserts. Unlike other ships, that tend to repeat items at different places, not here. You had to scan the whole thing because it was different at each area. Also, there were connections between some of the areas that would contain even more stuff like bread stations, salad bars, and cheese service. The setup itself was nice because as far as we could tell, at least some part of the buffet was open from 5am until 11pm continuously, so there was always food available. Most notably, when you came back on board from an excursion, say at around 3:30, you could pop in and get something to eat. Other lines (looking at you Serenade of the Seas!) we had been on closed the buffet from 2-5pm. On RCCL that was a big problem because that ship (the Serenade) did not have a poolside grill, pizza, or ice cream. They were in the buffet. But, no such problem on Princess. It's open most all of the way through.

But even better than the hours and the selection was the quality of the food. I was bracing for the worst, thinking our Emerald experience might be a downward indicator, but man, was the food good. Also, the staff went out of their way to make us happy. One thing that happened to us. We had been doing a bunch of things around the ship and got up to eat late (after 8) and they were taking down one of the 3 lines. In that line they had a grilled shrimp entree that had been taken up and my wife said, "That sounded good". The line cook heard my wife and grabbed the serving bowl and offered the rest to my wife. As they looked a bit "off the line" for a minute, she politely passed. We found some other things, and sat down to eat our food. A few minutes later, here comes the cook, tapping my wife on the shoulder. Turns out, he is the Chef de Partie in charge of that particular line. He had brought my wife a bowl of steaming hot, freshly cooked shrimp. His name is Joel from the Philippines, and he became our friend for the rest of the cruise. Joel sat down with us and we all just started talking. He said that they all got a lot of joy out of our enjoyment of the buffet and that they take a lot of pride in it. He mentioned that not only are a lot of the MDR items at the buffet, but sometimes, it's better to get it there. For instance, they had Filet Mignon on the buffet one night. He said, sure, you can take the ones out of the serving dish and they are good, "but we'd be more than happy just to cook you one to order". From there, we were sold. There were so many good things on the buffet (Beef Wellington, Carved Turkey's, Ham, Filet, Crab Cakes, Shrimp Cocktail, Fried Shrimp, always 2-3 soups, on and on..). Another thing we liked on the buffet, and this is a Princess thing, is that when you sit to eat, you don't get your drink. There are servers all over the place to come and get your drink order and bring you (and refill) your drinks.

Other buffet highlights included one station would have an international night that had either a mongolian wok station (pick all of your ingredients and they cook it for you), a german night, crepes one night, fajitas, an asian "hot pot" creation, and a "Create your own pasta" station one night. I mention the last one because Princess, on their MDR menus, has static items and rotating items every night. One of the static items is a really good Fettuccine Alfredo. Back in the day, Princess used to serve this in a parmesan bowl. However, for the last few cruises, it's been on a regular plated bowl. However, my wife got a chicken Alfredo at this station in the buffet and when they brought it out, lo and behold, it's in the parmesan bowl. For the record, I got a spaghetti with meatballs that was fantastic.

I should also mention that one day for lunch, they had a whole sushi area that was excellent:

Sushi.JPG

Here's your shrimp cocktail, DCL fans!

HorizonShrimp.JPG

Now, this is not to say that the MDR paled in comparison. Actually, it was really good as well. One night, I had some dish that the TV Chef Curtis Stone created for the line that I could best describe as a pot roast cooked in red wine with a cheddar biscuit topping. This may be my favorite cruise meal ever. It was so, so good. They also had really interesting ice creams on their dessert menu. Two I remember were Butter Almond (so, so good) and some kind of "Kahlua Mascarpone" ice cream (also good!). Lobster night also did not disappoint. Service here was top notch as well. We had Anytime dining, but on the 3 nights we went to dinner, we didn't have to wait.

The Curtis Stone thing... Not sure what it's called (I think it was Beef Tenderloin Tips and Mushroom Cobbler), but it was SOOOO good...

CurtisStone.JPG

Finally, I should mention room service. For some reason, my DD (and her friend) would rather eat room service than just about anything else (though Alfredo's took them away from this quite a bit), and that's been true for a number of years regardless of line we were on. Princess has a rather large room service menu (bigger than DCL's) and I can't tell you how many times I came back to the room to find grilled cheese and cheese fries... Room service is still included on Princess. We would get some things as well and they were all good, but I will say, the cheese plate didn't have anything on DCL's All Hands on Deck...

Bottom line. I'd put the food options and quality on the Regal Princess up against ANY of the cruises I've taken. And the best part was... I didn't have to spend a dime on upcharged food to feel like I was eating really good food...

Upcoming... Entertainment, Kid's Area's, and General Thoughts...
 
Last edited:
The Food

So, one area where this ship really excelled was in it's food service. Unlike many mainline ships today, there are only 2 upcharge restaurants on the Regal Princess, being the Crown Grill (Steakhouse) and Sabatini's (an Italian place) and a for pay Gelato stand that was hardly ever used. We didn't eat at either during our cruise. One of the reasons we like Princess (and DCL, for that matter, and really CCL, though they have more pay places, they still have a bunch of free ones) is that the included food options are diverse and satisfactory. On the pool deck, there is the Trident Grill and Prego Pizza (pretty standard poolside cruise fare). Trident Grill would also have extra things like cheese fries, or wings, or BBQ on some nights in addition to the regular menu. There was also an included soft serve ice cream place by the pool. This stayed busy, unlike the Gelato stand off of the Piazza. Also on the Piazza is the International Cafe, which while being the main espresso coffee bar also is a 24/7 sandwich/soup/bistro/pastry kind of place. The food is all included, our go-to being the ever available ham and cheese croissant. Also of note, they always had 4 different kinds of cookies here (double chocolate being my favorite).

Another nice option is that on the 2nd sea day, Princess offers a pub lunch in the Crown Grill that is complimentary. This stayed busy and was really good.

View attachment 389840

A quick aside. My wife is Elite with Princess. Part of this means that by default, they put a minibar setup in our room. As neither of us are big drinkers, one of the nice things you can do is swap it out for other options, one of which is a 15-count Premium Coffee package for 2 people in the stateroom. So, DW and I had basically free specialty coffee drinks all week (Caramel Latte for me and Salted Caramel Latte for DW) and had plenty left to get DD and her friend Caramel Frappucinos a few times...

View attachment 389829

Another included option is the dedicated pizzeria, Alfredo's, off of the Piazza. This place was table service individual pizzas, pastas, and calzones. DD and her friend LOVED this place. They literally wanted to eat here every night. Pizzas were fantastic (they were good on deck too, but these are another level)

View attachment 389820


View attachment 389821

View attachment 389822

View attachment 389823

The MDR was very good as well, but we only went 3 nights. One night we went to Alfredo's and the other 3, we ate at the buffet, which brings me to: The Buffet.

Now, I am not usually a big fan of buffets. Cabanas is fine, but it's not the number one thing I think about on a DCL cruise. Carnival's buffets are "good" as well, but I don't remember much about it. RCCL's Windjammer (at least on the Serenade) was mediocre at best. On Princess, I had mixed experiences. Our first cruise on the Dawn Princess was great. The rest were in the fine, but don't remember much, and last summer, we sailed Emerald Princess to Alaska and it was downright not good (which surprised us). So, we didn't have big expectations going in. I had read that the buffet on the Royal class ships was better, but we were in for a very pleasant surprise when we got on board. Quite honestly, Regal Princess has the best buffet of any of the 23 cruises I've been on, and, it's not even close!

The buffet is huge. There are literally 3 different buffet areas as well as a 4th area that was dedicated to pastries and desserts. Unlike other ships, that tend to repeat items at different places, not here. You had to scan the whole thing because it was different at each area. Also, there were connections between some of the areas that would contain even more stuff like bread stations, salad bars, and cheese service. The setup itself was nice because as far as we could tell, at least some part of the buffet was open from 5am until 11pm continuously, so there was always food available. Most notably, when you came back on board from an excursion, say at around 3:30, you could pop in and get something to eat. Other lines (looking at you Serenade of the Seas!) we had been on closed the buffet from 2-5pm. On RCCL that was a big problem because that ship (the Serenade) did not have a poolside grill, pizza, or ice cream. They were in the buffet. But, no such problem on Princess. It's open most all of the way through.

But even better than the hours and the selection was the quality of the food. I was bracing for the worst, thinking our Emerald experience might be a downward indicator, but man, was the food good. Also, the staff went out of their way to make us happy. One thing that happened to us. We had been doing a bunch of things around the ship and got up to eat late (after 8) and they were taking down one of the 3 lines. In that line they had a grilled shrimp entree that had been taken up and my wife said, "That sounded good". The line cook heard my wife and grabbed the serving bowl and offered the rest to my wife. As they looked a bit "off the line" for a minute, she politely passed. We found some other things, and sat down to eat our food. A few minutes later, here comes the cook, tapping my wife on the shoulder. Turns out, he is the Chef de Partie in charge of that particular line. He had brought my wife a bowl of steaming hot, freshly cooked shrimp. His name is Joel from the Philippines, and he became our friend for the rest of the cruise. Joel sat down with us and we all just started talking. He said that they all got a lot of joy out of our enjoyment of the buffet and that they take a lot of pride in it. He mentioned that not only are a lot of the MDR items at the buffet, but sometimes, it's better to get it there. For instance, they had Filet Mignon on the buffet one night. He said, sure, you can take the ones out of the serving dish and they are good, "but we'd be more than happy just to cook you one to order". From there, we were sold. There were so many good things on the buffet (Beef Wellington, Carved Turkey's, Ham, Filet, Crab Cakes, Shrimp Cocktail, Fried Shrimp, always 2-3 soups, on and on..). Another thing we liked on the buffet, and this is a Princess thing, is that when you sit to eat, you don't get your drink. There are servers all over the place to come and get your drink order and bring you (and refill) your drinks.

Other buffet highlights included one station would have an international night that had either a mongolian wok station (pick all of your ingredients and they cook it for you), a german night, crepes one night, fajitas, an asian "hot pot" creation, and a "Create your own pasta" station one night. I mention the last one because Princess, on their MDR menus, has static items and rotating items every night. One of the static items is a really good Fettuccine Alfredo. Back in the day, Princess used to serve this in a parmesan bowl. However, for the last few cruises, it's been on a regular plated bowl. However, my wife got a chicken Alfredo at this station in the buffet and when they brought it out, lo and behold, it's in the parmesan bowl. For the record, I got a spaghetti with meatballs that was fantastic.

I should also mention that one day for lunch, they had a whole sushi area that was excellent:

View attachment 389841

Here's your shrimp cocktail, DCL fans!

View attachment 389834

Now, this is not to say that the MDR paled in comparison. Actually, it was really good as well. One night, I had some dish that the TV Chef Curtis Stone created for the line that I could best describe as a pot roast cooked in red wine with a cheddar biscuit topping. This may be my favorite cruise meal ever. It was so, so good. They also had really interesting ice creams on their dessert menu. Two I remember were Butter Almond (so, so good) and some kind of "Kahlua Mascarpone" ice cream (also good!). Lobster night also did not disappoint. Service here was top notch as well. We had Anytime dining, but on the 3 nights we went to dinner, we didn't have to wait.

The Curtis Stone thing... Not sure what it's called (I think it was Beef Tenderloin Tips and Mushroom Cobbler), but it was SOOOO good...

View attachment 389837

Finally, I should mention room service. For some reason, my DD (and her friend) would rather eat room service than just about anything else (though Alfredo's took them away from this quite a bit), and that's been true for a number of years regardless of line we were on. Princess has a rather large room service menu (bigger than DCL's) and I can't tell you how many times I came back to the room to find grilled cheese and cheese fries... Room service is still included on Princess. We would get some things as well and they were all good, but I will say, the cheese plate didn't have anything on DCL's All Hands on Deck...

Bottom line. I'd put the food options and quality on the Regal Princess up against ANY of the cruises I've taken. And the best part was... I didn't have to spend a dime on upcharged food to feel like I was eating really good food...

Upcoming... Entertainment, Kid's Area's, and General Thoughts...
Thanks for this awesome review. I seriously had no desire to sail Princess ever, but your review is changing my mind. I’m pretty sure this will be answered in your next section, but if not, could you tell us what they had for daily activities? We are huge fans of trivia, bingo, towel folding, food demos, and all the corny stuff that DCL and Carnival have. Thanks again, and I really look forward to your next section.
 
I really want to sail Princess. It's still too spendy for my budget but someday my kids will be grown and have jobs and maybe they can afford their own vacation!
 
Thanks for the review! I've been on Princess once - oddly enough on the old Regal Princess (which is now P&O's Pacific Dawn) and that was the genesis of getting me into cruising (even though we didn't do another one until Allure in 2013.

We've been looking to do Princess for our (almost annual) generational cruise, but my brother (with his toddler and upcoming newborn) read up on the on-board nurseries and was not a fan. So it seems like 2021 for us at the earliest for Princess.

We had also looked into an Oasis class RCCL ship as we've only done one RCCL cruise and it was a complete disaster, but we think that a LOT of that was due to the ship and we'd have liked to have given RCCL another try, but when we looked at non-DCL options, the Oasis class priced out much higher (30-80% higher) than comparable offerings on either Princess or Carnival (Note: We booked late, so that could have contributed to that. Also, the new NCL ships seemed higher as well).
Typical cruise pricing I think - cost gets higher as more rooms are booked.

One thing we were interested to try was that this is what Princess calls a "medallion class" cruise. Meaning, that instead of a cruise card, every passenger gets a small disc with a RFID chip in it. This is very similar to Disney's "Magic Bands", with the exception that Princess sends a lanyard, not a wristband for you to carry around.
Royal does something similar on their ships that use RFID (e.g. Harmony and Symphony). You can use your card or purchase a WOW band which does the same thing as the card. I don't believe they do proximity detection like you mentioned, but frankly I'm not concerned either way with that. The important thing to me is that the tech works as intended.

Curious to know - how did you distinguish between one another's medallions? Also how was the weight.

Regal Princess is centered around "The Piazza", where many of the shops, casino, and entertainment venues were located around. It was always lively and it seemed as though something was always going on here.
I do enjoy Royal's Promenade, and this sounds like it's the same kind of idea, but more vertical. One thing I didn't like about the (old) Regal Princess was that it wasn't always easy to find the venues around the ship. This could of course be attributed to it being an old ship. Nevertheless, it's nice to see cruise lines thinking about making things more cohesive.

So, one area where this ship really excelled was in it's food service.
This is one thing I remember vividly about Princess - food and service was top notch. There was an excellent (and waist-expanding) souffle every night. Mains were really good.

I think we really only ate at the buffet for breakfast, which of all the buffet breakfasts I've had, was definitely one of them. Then again, I don't expect much from buffet breakfasts, so when I get a deviation from the norm (e.g. congee on Harmony), it's noteworthy.

I should also mention that one day for lunch, they had a whole sushi area that was excellent:

sushi-jpg.389841
If I'm being honest, the sushi must have tasted better than it looked. The maki seems to be kind of sloppily made, and I can't tell if the rest is nigiri or pressed sushi. But so long as it tastes good, I suppose it's not that big a deal.
 
We went to Grand Turk in 2015 and it was nice, it was crowded because we were the second ship to arrive so all the spots were taken. We go again next year and I'm not that excited about it. I think we'll be the only ship in port, but with all the local vendors taking over the beach in front of the free chairs it looks hard to get a free spot where I can see the water. I'm not sure what we'll do this time, I have a year to decide I guess so time to think it over. We are also only in port a short time, but it's our second port (after Half Moon Cay which I am excited for) and I know we'll be needing some beach time! We may walk down to Jack's or do a beach excursion through the ship to get more space and less crowding. In theory any way. Since I travel with kiddo I'm not that comfortable renting anything to drive myself.

Look for "Home Sweet Home"... I have not tried it yet but it was our plan for our next visit to GT (that we finally changed for our upcoming cruise) The reviews are stellar!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

GET A DISNEY VACATION QUOTE

Dreams Unlimited Travel is committed to providing you with the very best vacation planning experience possible. Our Vacation Planners are experts and will share their honest advice to help you have a magical vacation.

Let us help you with your next Disney Vacation!


GET UP TO A $1000 SHIPBOARD CREDIT AND AN EXCLUSIVE GIFT!

If you make your Disney Cruise Line reservation with Dreams Unlimited Travel you’ll receive these incredible shipboard credits to spend on your cruise!















facebook twitter
Top