My favorite dining experience was our first trip to WDW in Aug 08.at the princess dinner at the Arkershus. My DD(11) was ten at the time. As with most "tweens" she has made the move from Barbie Princess's to Hannah Montana and the Jonus Brothers.
Well anyhow, we gave her the option to do character dinners or not. Other than her wanting to go to a fancy dinner(we ended up doing Narcoosee's) she wanted to do the CRT but we couldn't get in. Instead we ended up doing the princess instead in Norway.
It was priceless to watch my daughter change from that little girl wanting to grow up so fast to her being daddy's little princess all over again. I am not ashamed to say this, but it actually brought tears to my eyes. She was absolutely thrilled to see the princesses. She was so excited to see her favorite princess in Ariel actually show up at our table. When she saw her from across the restaurant she was like a 6 year old all over again.
We are going back in 5 days and we have ADR's this time to CRT. I'm sure that the magic won't be the same as it was in August but I'm sure I'll still get the chance to see the "little girl" in my daughter one last time in WDW.