I've used Uber/Lyft several times from MCO to property. I usually arrive at almost the same time of evening (between 9-10pm) and usually on a Tuesday (cuz that's when I find the cheapest flights) and pricing has varied from $27-$37. I always go to the same destination.
While I'm standing at the conveyor waiting for my bag I always open up both the Uber and the Lyft app and pick whichever is the cheapest. Sometimes it's 30 cents difference between the two and sometimes it's $10 or so.
(oh, I always use UberX or Lyft...whateverTheBasicOneIsCalled.)