This actually just happened to us. Our trip starts on Aug. 22 and our passes expired on Aug. 23. So we were able to book our first 2 days of FPs and then had to renew our annual passes. I called MS on June 22 and they allowed me to renew then. I believe it was about 62 days before they expired. Maybe it was allowed because I explained I couldn't make my FPs for the remainder of our trip or maybe I was just lucky.
To the OP I would suggest calling and asking if you can renew if you are actually anywhere near the 60 day window. From reading your post I am assuming you are not really that close. But I guess it can't hurt to ask. The gift card idea seems like a good second option. Good luck.
Let me update you on this issue.... You see, I CONTACTED Guest Relations. Today? I got a phone call....
Much as I had suspected.... NO ONE ACTUALLY THOUGHT ABOUT THIS. The DVC renewal windows were there BEFORE FP even existed
And each department decided to pick the SAME 60 day renewal window
.
What I suggested.... STAGGER the renewal windows. There are at least 3 ways to do this
1) Expand renewal window for AP to 70 days for a verified on site visitor (all DB logic, all math - OPTIMUM).
2) Reduce 60 day FP booking window to 50 days for on site guests. Keep AP renewal window at 60 days (much LESS than optimum).
3) Give up... you lack the ability to adjust to interdepartmental issues, and have decided to NOT be one company. We'll deal with it.
WDW will do what they choose to do. In the interim? Depending on your AP renewal window, ALL AP holders are NOT granted a 60 day window for FP reservations... that is simple fact, based on a poor corporate interdepartmental choice. The issue will affect FEW people, depending on your AP renewal window. MOST people will just get lucky, and not experience this issue.
Given the time frame of this issue.... WDW was not being "evil" - they just never THOUGHT about it. Folks? They screwed up. People do that, on occasion.
So - today? If your AP expires at the beginning, middle, or end of your vacation.... you will only be able to book FPs until your VALID TICKET expires. You must then renew when WDW ALLOWS you to, and book your other FPs.
All previous data conveyed based on Guest Services telephone conversation.... I'm not right, you aren't wrong....If you have other opinions, please convey communication DATA.