Tuesday was mostly ridiculous for us but we made do with the ridiculous crowds. Some notes to help anyone:
-As posted earlier, I got into the party with my wristband as a DVC member around 3:00 and got in line for Jack and Sally immediately. I was around the 25th person in line and they started greeting guests around 4:35, I was done at 4:55. Great interaction as usual.
-Family arrived at the parks as soon as I was finished. They wanted to watch the Flag Retreat, then we went through the party bypass. We stopped at 3 or 4 photo ops in the bypass and picked up our first bag of candy.
-We got into the Standby line for Buzz and waited about 30 minutes at 5:45.
-Picked up the pumpkin spice milkshake at Auntie Gravity's. Crazy behind the counter but a short wait. PS Milkshake was AWESOME, AWESOME, AWESOME! I hated the holiday "cookie butter" one last year but knew I had to try the pumpkin spice one and I was correct to do so. Best Halloween treat I've ever had in my three MNSSHPs.
-We headed to meet Donald and Daisy at around 6:40 and there were maybe 10 people in front of us. They came out at 7:00 and we finished up around 7:15. Great interaction! Tons of fun. These ended up being our last characters of the night.
-We split up for a little bit since I really wanted to do Space Mountain but the rest of the family doesn't do it. Posted wait was 40 for Space, I waited about 20. AMAZING experience! So much fun and I was genuinely scared at points. LOVE those unexpected drops in the dark! In the ~40 minutes it took for me to reach my family again from start to finish, they had done 3 separate treat trails in Fantasyland and had just gotten off Winnie the Pooh.
-We did the treat trail in Philharmagic. The line looked long, but the entire experience took maybe 5 minutes. Also-- as you're leaving, the Philhar gift shop has a board with a bunch of Disney villains. If you can name them all, you get a prize! (It's a lollipop)
-Haunted Mansion area was packed as expected. We waited maybe 20 minutes to do HM and saw Madame Carlotta interact with guests for a little while. We also waited about 15 minutes for the lantern pic.
This is where the party unfortunately went downhill for us. We battled the crowd waiting for the first parade by "swimming upstream" on that bridge across from the Frontierland shops/CBJ/Pecos, and that's when we realized we were all exhausted already from battling the park crowds. We bought the Mickey Pumpkin balloon popcorn bucket and had dinner at Pecos Bill, then caught the fireworks show from an obstructed view next to the Christmas Shop in Liberty Square. DSis wanted the headless horseman pumpkin cheesecake from Sleepy Hollow and waited 15 minutes for it once the fireworks were over. Everyone took a bite of it and agreed it was pretty bad. Then we headed towards Main Street. I waited 20 minutes to buy a MNSSHP halloween shirt and then left after catching a glimpse of the Headless Horseman. In my 3 parties, this is the first time I've ever seen him, so that was awesome! The rest of the family caught the Boo to You Parade near City Hall, but I went home. I was completely exhausted and a little cranky, and while I love Boo to You, the crowds had not thinned out as usual in time for the 11:15 parade and I was ready to call it a night. The rest of the family had no trouble leaving the parks at the end of the parade, as they were towards the very front of the park and therefore at the front of the "herd" leaving after the second parade.
The only thing we did not get to do that we really wanted to do was go on PotC with the live actors. We also missed out on a few snacks we wanted to try, but that didn't bother us as much. I love the Villain's Spelltacular, but the family had no interest, so I didn't push it. Hub was a mess from start to finish.
I give our party experience a 6/10. Certainly the worst out of the parties I've been to, but having fair expectations going in, it "feels" like we did more than I thought we were going to do, and it's still my favorite time of year to be in Magic. I think I'm mostly upset that my family's first MNSSHP was too crowded to do a few more things we wanted to do, but they insist that they had a good time and I also had some great moments, so all's well that ends well, I guess! We also have Moonlight Magic planned for tonight, which we're really looking forward to, but our experience at MNSSHP has definitely curbed our expectations for it. Thankfully, MM tickets are distributed well in advance and heavily capped, so the party pass people and the "last minute SWGE crowd" won't be an issue tonight.
There was a time where I recommended every single person I came across to do MNSSHP at least once, but now, I'm not so sure I do. If you love Halloween with all your heart, and let's face it-- there are some pretty cool things to eat, characters to meet, and entertainment to watch at this party-- I say go for it as long as you know that you're not going to find smaller crowds than a regular week day. In fact, I thought the party was more crowded than Magic Kingdom was on Sunday or yesterday... and yesterday was supposed to be the most crowded day at MK this week! But if you're looking for a unique MK experience with shorter lines, skip it and go to DAH.
Sorry for the essay
If you're going to the party this season, have so much fun! Will be watching to see how/if crowds change at all this season.