It depends a TON on the day. To illustrate:
Last Wednesday, Feb. 12, was a VERY EMPTY day. So, at 4:26pm, FP return times looked like the first return time I listed here, with tons of immediate availability and very little "evening" available. This Tuesday, Feb. 18 was a CROWDED day. The latest FP capture I did was at 1:06pm, so that's 3 hours and 20 minutes
earlier in the day, and look how different the return times are - they're the second return time in
bold.
Again, the first listed return time is from 4:26pm on Wednesday, Feb. 12; the second, bolded, return time is from 1:06pm on Tuesday, Feb. 18.
Three and a half hours earlier in the day, but six days later:
Autopia: 5:00,
4:25
Big Thunder: 4:25,
6:45
Buzz: 4:45,
3:40
Goofy's Sky School: 4:25,
2:25
Grizzly: closed for Refurb,
2:00
GOTG: 5:35,
6:40
Haunted Mansion: closed for Refurb
Incredicoaster: 6:35,
3:00
Indiana Jones: 5:35,
9:05
IASW: 4:25,
2:45
Matterhorn: 6:40,
8:35
Monster's Inc: 4:25,
2:35
RSR: gone,
gone
Roger Rabbit: 4:30,
2:50
Soarin: 5:15,
5:55
Space Mountain: 6:30,
9:55
Splash Mountain: 4:25,
5:15
Star Tours: 4:25,
4:45
Toy Story: 8:40,
gone
This is why I say FP availability varies a lot. RSR alone has run out by 10:30am and after 4pm
this month alone.
P.S. I realize the side-by-side would be a lot more useful if the time of day was the same for both; I just happened to have these two lists still undeleted on my phone, and I don't have access to my other data at this moment.