Most, if not all, of the pins you trade with CMs are the ones that are often called "fake"....but when pressed for ways to tell they're "fake"....the typical response from those who poo-poo ebay purchases is that it has the same markings as the "real" ones but they just "look and feel" different. So PPs kids probably traded their "fake" for other peoples' "fake" pins. Since the kids love their pins, and aren't looking for future investment pins, I don't see what difference it makes. We got taken by a guest trade our first week of pin collecting....he told my daughter the Ariel she wanted was "very rare" and insisted he'd only trade it for 2 of hers....after I made sure she understood....she willingly did so.......the next day she found the same exact pin on a CM lanyard and was so excited to think she could get one for her sister.....only to have the CM say it wasn't rare at all, in fact could be purchased at the pin shop in the park.....we made our first venture into a pin shop to find yep, it was an $8 pin. Our second time talking to a guest was when we had a discussion with a "professional pin trader" (his title, not mine)....and then showed him the pins we had.....after looking closely at them (my daughter wanted to trade for one of his) he proclaimed them "all fakes" and refused to trade with her and started being rather rude about what he perceived as her trying to rip people off....I was a few yards away and upon hearing him, I walked up to stop him and I produced the receipt for 6 of them that we had bought from the Emporium in the last couple of days (that he had just proclaimed fake) and he all but told me I was a liar and that Emporium doesn't sell fakes so I couldn't have purchased them from there. Being so very new to pin trading, and having our second ugly transaction of the week, and the thought that I bought fake pins from Disney themselves, I went in and talked with a manager at Emporium. According to her, most self-proclaimed professional traders don't know how to tell the difference except for the ones without the Disney mark on the back.....because the "fakes" being sold are 99% ones that were made in the same factory as the "real" ones that they sell....but that the China factory makes more and sells them independently. Very enlightening conversation. Now my children do not attempt trades with guests. CMs will trade any pin with the Disney mark on them. If Disney felt they were fakes and therefore should not be traded, then CMs wouldn't be allowed to do so. Over the last 10 years we have traded thousands of pins, all of which we bought from ebay in bulk, and in all those pins we have never been refused a trade from a CM. We LOVE to trade with CMs....and then to talk to them about Pins, Characters and Disney....we have made friends with several CMs and look forward to seeing them each trip. If you want to enhance your pin trading, be sure to start up a conversation with the CM beyond "can I see your pins, and trade you this one".
We have received some from ebay that were scratched and certainly wouldn't interest a "professional trader" but my kids love the pins so they don't mind the minor scratches. I guess it all depends on what you are trading for.....monetary value or the joy of having a beautiful pin of your favorite character.
We, and our "fake" pins will be arriving in WDW in 2 weeks, and we'll spend the next month trading the 200 pins we each have....so if you feel those bought on ebay are all fakes.....be aware, we're coming, lol! We are probably the ones that have already traded with the CM, but stick around and talk to them while they trade with other guests...say hello to us too!