I think it is so interesting to hear such opposite opinions of the same meal!
I have to think that my opinion was very much colored by the cost of the meal. None of the food was "bad", although I did not care for the bacon and sausage which is often the case when I eat out for some reason. The potato casserole was ok, the fruit and cheese were fine, I did think the danish and breads were not fresh but they were not horrible or bad tasting, the eggs were very tasty and hot...
However, we were not on the dining plan and I think that $30 per person over the age of 9 was ridiculous and I just kept thinking I am paying $140 for my family basically to eat a plate of scrambled eggs! Maybe we are just buffet people and I was just expecting something different. Even at the Cinderella castle meal there was French toast as well as eggs if I recall correctly. This meal just seemed to have too little of a variety of food. If they added pancakes/waffles/french toast it would have helped. Maybe even a waffle station where they make fresh waffles would have been nice.
Don't get me wrong, we all left feeling full (maybe it was the 3 plates of eggs that we ate!!) but certainly not worth the $$$ even with the photos and the princesses.