A hit for me were an electric skillet and a laptop from DH (now I don't have to borrow my mom's skillet anymore)
For both of us, it was the crock pot hook ups my mom got us. For DH it was a gift certificate for ThinkGeek.com.
For DS12 it was a 4 ball bowling bag. He gets his 4th bowling ball this month from the Scholarship league he is on. Other hits for him were a few Xbox One games, zippered sweatshirt jacket and a nice, warm throw blanket that DH and I picked for him at BJ's.
I think we only had one flop and that was a lap desk that I had picked up for DS. It seemed a great idea at the time, but I should have checked it to make sure the light worked on it before wrapping it. After DS opened it, we put batteries in and the light didn't work. Ok, that's not a big thing, it could still be used, except I immediately noticed that it was smoking! Great, there went that gift
. We took it back to the store where I got it from and returned it. We got the refund back, which was good and I told them not to put it back out on the floor due to the defect. The only problem we had was that the store didn't have any more of them. It was The Christmas Tree Shops, which I've found that if you find something you like and don't get it then, they won't have it when you go back. Kind of reminds me of Home Goods