I wouldn't worry about it if the CDC had made this change when the US population was, say, 70% vaccinated, but 36% is just too soon, IMO.
I agree. I wish they had worded their new guidance differently. They could have shared the good news about how effective the vaccines are at protecting vaccinated people by maybe stating that it’s safe for fully vaccinated people to forgo masks in *private* settings/gatherings or public places outdoors, and still encourage unvaccinated people to get vaccinated by making removal of mask mandates for indoor settings dependent on either 70% of a state’s population (total population, not just adults) being fully vaccinated (not just one shot) OR new case numbers/hospitalizations/deaths statewide being negligible, whichever comes first. States could have countdown tickers to help keep everyone updated and encourage people to help towards achieving the goal of removing the indoor mandates.
Although I trust the vaccines are protecting against the current variants, the more unvaccinated people not masking/distancing/etc., the more likely they are to potentially be the host that causes the variant that our current vaccines don’t protect against, possibly undoing all our progress. And we all know requiring unvaccinated/partially vaccinated to mask, but leaving it up to the honor system and not requiring proof means that lots of unvaccinated people will stop masking. Getting out of this pandemic is a race against the clock. Can we get enough people vaccinated and starve the virus hosts before it mutates in a way that messes up our current vaccine efficacy?
The COVID numbers have been trending in a good direction, and lots of people are now vaccinated, with more eligible now that 12+ can be vaccinated, but I really hope they didn’t jump the gun by not waiting just 1 or 2 more months. In my state, we’re at 48% with one dose, with obviously less than that fully vaccinated, and we’re in the top half of the country in terms of percentage of population vaccinated, which means more than half the states are even less vaccinated than we are. Even the number 1 state, Maine, only has 48% fully vaccinated. In terms of one dose, the number 1 state, Vermont, has 63%.
In my state, because of the new CDC guidelines, our mask mandate ended yesterday at midnight for fully vaccinated people (with exceptions) although unvaccinated/partially vaccinated are still required to mask pretty much everywhere. These places are the exceptions where everyone must still mask in my state, vaccinated or not:
- k-12 school settings, which I think is smart since even in high schools where 16+ have had a little more time to get vaccinated, tons of students still aren’t. In elementary schools no students are eligible to be vaccinated yet, and in middle schools even those newly eligible may barely have had their second shot by the last day of school. Looking at the active “outbreak” data in my area, it’s almost all in schools and daycares, so easing restrictions in these settings doesn’t seem smart.
- medical buildings,
- public transport,
- “congregate settings”, which from what I can tell seems to mean jails, nursing homes, churches/places of worship, and maybe large entertainment venues
- any business that wants to require everyone wear a mask
Around here, I can’t really tell what mask requirements have actually changed other than stores/restaurants, and since it seems it is up to each individual business, it’s going to be very confusing. I went to the grocery store today (Giant) and every single person I saw in there was masked. I’m not sure if the store was still requiring it, but I am assuming yes since I didn’t see a single person, customer or employee, without a mask. I saw an article that said Walmart, Costco (except the pharmacy and optical centers since they are “medical” so everyone must mask in those areas) and Trader Joes are now allowing vaccinated people to not wear masks, but Target and Kroger still require them for everyone, at least for now.