HELP WANTED: Which of these two Signature restaurants do you prefer?

[jabead]

Please help determine the winner of Round II of my Signature Smackdown competition between Artist Point and Narcoossee's. (See my ongoing Dining Review for further details.)

If you have only been to one of these restaurants and had a good experience then give that restaurant your vote. If the experience was not good, then vote for the other restaurant. And if you haven't been to either one then vote for the one you would most like to try.

Thanks for your help!


Here is a link to my Dining Review (see Post# 175 for more on the WWD Signature Smackdown):

http://www.disboards.com/showthread.php?t=2600277&page=12

 

[laurainsem]

We haven't yet eaten at Artist Pointe but plan to!

Narcoossee's was super yummy. I had the whole Maine Lobster (tasted nice and fresh) and my sister had the filet mignon which was also excellent.

 

[jabead]

We haven't yet eaten at Artist Pointe but plan to!

Narcoossee's was super yummy. I had the whole Maine Lobster (tasted nice and fresh) and my sister had the filet mignon which was also excellent.

Wow, you were quick...I don't think I even had the poll part of my post up yet when you responded Thanks for your opinion and please vote in the poll if you haven't already.

 

[Ela1972]

Voted for narcoossees.

We went on the rainiest, coldest most miserable night in February but you couldn't beat watching wishes and the food was pretty good too.

 

[NJEeyore]

Artist Point Is consistently underrated on the boards. It is our must do every trip. We have gone as a couple, as a family and as a group and always had good service. As with any restaurant, if you go 10 times things change; menu items, service, waitstaff. But this place has remained consistent over time. Nice wine list and nice lounge for before or after dinner drink(or both).

 

[PamelaKay]

I voted for Artist Point.

I have eaten at both and several times at Narcoosees. The food at Narcoosees is very good and you can see the fireworks at the MK, but the last 2 times I have eaten there, the service was terrible.

The food at Artist Point is wonderful and the service is outstanding.

If you are looking for food and views, Narcoosees, but if you want food and great service, I would go for Artist Point.

 

[jpeka65844]

Never done Narcoossee's but thumbs up for AP. Fabulous service, great food, great atmosphere. What's not to love?

 

[jabead]

We haven't yet eaten at Artist Pointe but plan to!

Narcoossee's was super yummy. I had the whole Maine Lobster (tasted nice and fresh) and my sister had the filet mignon which was also excellent.

Voted for narcoossees.

We went on the rainiest, coldest most miserable night in February but you couldn't beat watching wishes and the food was pretty good too.

I voted for Artist Point.

I have eaten at both and several times at Narcoosees. The food at Narcoosees is very good and you can see the fireworks at the MK, but the last 2 times I have eaten there, the service was terrible.

The food at Artist Point is wonderful and the service is outstanding.

If you are looking for food and views, Narcoosees, but if you want food and great service, I would go for Artist Point.

Artist Point Is consistently underrated on the boards. It is our must do every trip. We have gone as a couple, as a family and as a group and always had good service. As with any restaurant, if you go 10 times things change; menu items, service, waitstaff. But this place has remained consistent over time. Nice wine list and nice lounge for before or after dinner drink(or both).

Never done Narcoossee's but thumbs up for AP. Fabulous service, great food, great atmosphere. What's not to love?

Thank you to all of you for voting and taking the time to post your thoughts about these restaurants. I hope you all don't mind, but I've added your comments to my Dining Review thread too.

 

[jabead]

Just bumping this up to Page 1 to try and get more votes and comments.

 

[mickeynut1]

We haven't eaten at Narcoossee's (planning on trying it on our next trip), but we LOVED Artist Point . We had filet and salmon and both were amazing and the service was great

 

[jabead]

Bumping up again...'cause the more votes and comments, the more reliable the results. So please keep them coming. Thanks!

 

[j&j620]

We ate at both restaurants in August and have ADRs for both again in July because we enjoyed each place's food and ambiance so much. I voted for AP, though, because our service was phenomenal!

 

[WendyWuWu]

Never been to Narcoosses but AP was fantastic.
http://distickers.com/ticker/tickers/klh1cjj8ivat7cy7.png

 

[jabead]

We haven't eaten at Narcoossee's (planning on trying it on our next trip), but we LOVED Artist Point . We had filet and salmon and both were amazing and the service was great

We ate at both restaurants in August and have ADRs for both again in July because we enjoyed each place's food and ambiance so much. I voted for AP, though, because our service was phenomenal!

Never been to Narcoosses but AP was fantastic.
http://distickers.com/ticker/tickers/klh1cjj8ivat7cy7.png

Thank you to all of you for taking the time to add a comment. And thank you to everyone who has voted so far.

 

[topmonkeygirl]

We plan on doing Artist Point on our next trip, can't wait. We did Narcoossee's last time and plan on returning every trip. There was not one negative about the whole experience. The food, service, atmosphere, view, just everything about the whole place was exceptional. My husband (not a foodie, nor does he like to eat out) raved about this place, something he never does. He also said that is one place he definately wants to visit again.

 

[CoolDisneyCat]

I voted for Narcoossee's. Each time we have eaten there the food and service have been wonderful!

 

[jabead]

We plan on doing Artist Point on our next trip, can't wait. We did Narcoossee's last time and plan on returning every trip. There was not one negative about the whole experience. The food, service, atmosphere, view, just everything about the whole place was exceptional. My husband (not a foodie, nor does he like to eat out) raved about this place, something he never does. He also said that is one place he definately wants to visit again.

I voted for Narcoossee's. Each time we have eaten there the food and service have been wonderful!

Thanks for your comments!

 

[Mamu]

We have done both and while Nascooeess's is a very good restaurant with a great location, I actually enjoy Artist Point more.

 

[Cee]

I've only been to Artists Pointe but hoping to try the other soon. AP is wonderful. Fine dining at it's very best.

 

[jabead]

We have done both and while Nascooeess's is a very good restaurant with a great location, I actually enjoy Artist Point more.

I've only been to Artists Pointe but hoping to try the other soon. AP is wonderful. Fine dining at it's very best.

Two more for Artist Point. Thanks for posting your opinions!