Okay I'm now here to follow along in the last stretch
We are doing CBR for the exact same reasons as you. We started out at CSR, but when the gift card offer came out we were wiling to switch. All the extra things you mentioned like characters and welcome gifts have me even more excited that we decided to do it.
Marie and I have also considered the ice cream social but yeah, for the price, it just doesn't seem worth it. I think next year we're considering doing Tony's? I don't love FoF enough to wait and since they did away with fastpasses it's even more that I don't see the point in waiting. I guess we'll see what happens. I don't let other people scare me away from things though. Probably because I'm a large holder of unpopular Disney opinions, so I don't trust others anyway.
This is me. Right now I'm just so down because I have nothing left to plan and unlike Marie, since I'm job searching I don't even have work to keep me busy. So it's like, I've got all this time left until the trip and practically nothing to fill it with. I am for sure already thinking about our next trip to keep me busy.
Also, I hope we run into each other at the party! And perhaps the PotC screening, cause we're hoping to get in on that as well.