The closest to any of those I've stayed at was the Dolphin in 2015. I absolutely adored the location; being within walking distance of 2 parks was a huge perk (and allowed us to visit DHS with confidence on the morning of our departure day, knowing we wouldn't miss our ride to the airport due to a delayed bus). The hotel itself, though...meh. It's a nice hotel, to be sure, but the theme seemed to just be "nice hotel" and the whole point of Disney (for me, at least) is feeling more immersed in the experience than that. Between that and lacking various conveniences you get with the actual Disney resorts (no Magical Express, parking's not included, and it created more logistical issues with proving we were staying onsite when entering attractions during evening Extra Magic Hours), I don't think I would do Swolphin again.