My experience less than two weeks ago was such that I would NOT recommend Captn Jack's. Diff'rent strokes for diff'rent folks.
I thought the crab cakes were incredibly salty, the slaw had an odd flavor, and the lobster tails were just so-so. Our server wasn't friendly with us and rushed us through the meal at lightening pace. The ONLY bright spot was the white chocolate raspberry cheesecake. Now that was a great dessert!
Glad you like it there, though. However, we won't be back.