Have you ever cooked your turkey ahead of time?

maslex

DIS Veteran
Joined
Apr 15, 2006
Messages
5,113
I'm having Christmas dinner at my house this year and doing a full turkey dinner. My house is really small and it's gonna be a full house so I'd like to make and slice up the turkey the day before and reheat it somehow the next day.

Any suggestions?
 
I'm having Christmas dinner at my house this year and doing a full turkey dinner. My house is really small and it's gonna be a full house so I'd like to make and slice up the turkey the day before and reheat it somehow the next day.

Any suggestions?

Internet has methods to cook a turkey overnight. We did one for Thanksgiving this year in an electric roasting pan. Fell apart- so moist and tender, that dh had little carving to do. Trisha Yearwood mentioned it on her cooking show.

My inlaws have cooked the turkey ahead of time. Sliced it. Placed in aluminum pans covered in a can of chicken broth to keep from drying out. Warm the pans in the oven before you want to eat
 
Internet has methods to cook a turkey overnight. We did one for Thanksgiving this year in an electric roasting pan. Fell apart- so moist and tender, that dh had little carving to do. Trisha Yearwood mentioned it on her cooking show.

My inlaws have cooked the turkey ahead of time. Sliced it. Placed in aluminum pans covered in a can of chicken broth to keep from drying out. Warm the pans in the oven before you want to eat

Never thought to get an electric roaster. What brand do you have? Might have to see if they gave one on a cyber Monday sale
 
We have done it before because we need more than one turkey with our big family. What I have done is slice it ahead of time and put it in aluminum pans with some turkey or chicken broth. Cover tightly and heat up in a low oven about an hour before dinner. Works great.
 
Yes. I have done this the last several years. Pre-covid, when we had a large group over, I would cook two smaller turkeys on Christmas Eve day (instead of one big one).
After cooking, I store the carved turkey in rubbermaid container and pour a little broth over the top.
It took me trying several diff methods for reheating, but by far the best was to invest in a casserole style crockpot. Lay the turkey in, pour a little chicken broth over the top and heat until hot. It turns out just perfectly. Plus it keeps the turkey warm all through dinner.
 
Might try cooking a turkey breast instead. It cooks in far less time then a whole bird and the white meat tends to be what most people eat and far easier to carve for serving then dark meat or drumsticks. We were never big on cooking turkey ahead of time and then rewarming since the results tasted like leftovers the first time you served it.
 
Not sure if you have the space or have it in the budget, but we got a large capacity (22qt) self basting roaster a couple of years ago that can handle up to a 26lb turkey. It sits out of the way plugged in on a table (still enough room for people to sit at that table and have space for some snack plates) and frees up the oven/stove for everything else. Ours is an Oster brand one and was something like $45-50 at Costco. Our specific model is either out of stock or jacked up in price due to the holidays, but I see Walmart has something very similar. Brand is Aroma, capacity is the same, looks nearly identical, price is in the previous range noted, and the reviews are good. We cook turkey dinner 3-4x a year in it and use it for big potlucks and parties as well. So, it's not a bad thing to have around and is a lifesaver for big holidays.
 
I'm having Christmas dinner at my house this year and doing a full turkey dinner. My house is really small and it's gonna be a full house so I'd like to make and slice up the turkey the day before and reheat it somehow the next day.

Any suggestions?
Frequently roasted birds ahead of time in the past. A brinded bird is easiest as it stays moist longer. Reheating it on an electric griddle or warming tray is simple when pre sliced. Great time to use small crock pots and fondue pots to keep sides and gravies warm.make your gravy in advance if possible; same for cranberry sauce.
 
My inlaws have cooked the turkey ahead of time. Sliced it. Placed in aluminum pans covered in a can of chicken broth to keep from drying out. Warm the pans in the oven before you want to eat

::yes:: I was just going to recommend this. The broth is essential to not drying out in the fridge and so there is moisture while reheating in the oven.
 
I'm having Christmas dinner at my house this year and doing a full turkey dinner. My house is really small and it's gonna be a full house so I'd like to make and slice up the turkey the day before and reheat it somehow the next day.

Any suggestions?
I started doing this a couple of years ago. It's SOOOOOO much nicer not to have be in the kitchen all day with preparing the turkey, as well as all the other stuff that goes along with it.

Here's the instructions I use:

Step 1. Roast the turkey.

Step 2. When done, cover it loosely with foil and let it rest for 30-45 minutes. This allows the juices to settle into the meat before it is cut. If you cut it too soon the juices will run out, resulting in a dry turkey.

Step 3. Carve the turkey.

  • Cut the turkey breast in 3/4" thick slices. If you slice it too thinly, the turkey won't hold in the juices as well and remain as moist.
Step 4. Place the sliced turkey in a baking pan that will fit in your refrigerator. Keep the sliced pieces pressed together.

Step 5. Cover the sliced turkey with plastic wrap, pressing it down to close any air pockets. This also helps retain moisture in the turkey.

Step 6. Cover the pan with a lid or piece of aluminum foil and refrigerate.
626820


Here's how to reheat and serve the turkey.

Step 7.
Remove turkey from fridge and rest on counter for 30-45 minutes to allow it to return to room temperature

Step 8. Remove the plastic wrap and spread out the turkey slices in an even layer. For quick, even heating, it's best to spread the slices in a single layer, overlapping them slightly--don't stack them if you can avoid it.

Step 9. Drizzle chicken or turkey broth evenly over all of the sliced meat. You can use canned broth or make your own. Cover pan tightly with aluminum foil.



Step 10. Reheat the turkey without overcooking it.

If you've taken care to roast your turkey properly so that it has remained moist, you don't want to undo that by overcooking it and drying it out during the reheating process. There are two methods; choose the one that works best for you. With both methods, the turkey should be in an even shallow layer in a baking pan. If it's piled too high, the outside layers will overcook before the center layers are hot.

  • FLASH REHEATING at a high temperature is a method often used by restaurants chefs. The concept is simple. Put room temperature food in shallow, covered pans, and put it in a 450 degree oven for approx. 7-15 minutes. It heats the food fast (in a FLASH) without cooking it further. This is the method I recommend if you don't need the oven set to a lower temperature for cooking other dishes at the same time.
  • STANDARD REHEATING in a 350 degree oven is another option that normally will take 25-30 minutes for room temperature turkey to be heated through. This method is the best option if you have other dishes that need to cook in the oven at the same time at that temperature.
Either way, the important thing is to remove the turkey from the oven as soon as it's heated through completely without letting it overcook. Ovens and cooking times can vary, so I recommend checking on it about half way into the reheating process to help you gauge when to remove it from the oven.

Step 11. Transfer the hot turkey to a serving platter. I like to use a fish spatula for this--it's nice and long, so I can neatly transfer a whole row of turkey slices at once.

Step 12. Drizzle 2-3 tablespoons of hot broth over the turkey just before serving. There should be some hot broth in the bottom of the reheating pan that can be used for this.
 
Last edited:
I can see preparing the sides ahead of time, but for me, the turkey being cooked the day of and "presented" is an important part of the festivities. But I'm not a big fan of leftover reheated turkey in the first place. So much better right after it has come out of the oven.,
 
I can see preparing the sides ahead of time, but for me, the turkey being cooked the day of and "presented" is an important part of the festivities. But I'm not a big fan of leftover reheated turkey in the first place. So much better right after it has come out of the oven.,
I opted to switch because, by the time I spend all day in the kitchen preparing the meal, I just wasn't hungry any more and couldn't enjoy the food.

Now, I can get the meal together and on the table in an hour and a half, instead of it taking my whole day on the day that I should also be able to enjoy the festivities.
 
We've always cooked the turkey or turkey breast the night before.

Slice, put in appropriate baking container, pour chicken or turkey broth all over. Cover with aluminum foil.

Reheat the next day for about an hour. Turkey stays moist.

As for the "presentation: part. :rotfl2: Nobody gives a damn about the freshly roasted turkey being brought to the table for grandpop to carve. It's more of a hassle than anything, and grandpop, who otherwise couldn't boil water, slashes the hell out of the poor bird.

That Norman Rockwell crap makes me wanna puke.

But I do hope everyone had a Divine Thanksgiving.

626822
 
As for the "presentation: part. :rotfl2: Nobody gives a damn about the freshly roasted turkey being brought to the table for grandpop to carve. It's more of a hassle than anything, and grandpop, who otherwise couldn't boil water, slashes the hell out of the poor bird.

That Norman Rockwell crap makes me wanna puke.

But I do hope everyone had a Divine Thanksgiving.

View attachment 626822

For some, the presentation of the turkey is a religious experience!
 
I opted to switch because, by the time I spend all day in the kitchen preparing the meal, I just wasn't hungry any more and couldn't enjoy the food.

Now, I can get the meal together and on the table in an hour and a half, instead of it taking my whole day on the day that I should also be able to enjoy the festivities.
We opted to make changes to the menu to reduce preparation time. Mostly we reduced the number of items. And this year just having three for Thanksgiving dinner........and Christmas dinner......will make a big difference. We bought a boneless turkey breast, open the package, 2 hours in the oven it's ready. Pies were made the day before. Loaf of french bread cubed for stuffing the week before and allowed to dry. Sauteed onion and celery, season and bake. One sweet potato diced and baked. Yukon gold potatoes, cubed, boiled, mixed with fresh garlic cloves and mashed. Broccoli microwaved, poof, it's dinner.
 
Another thing: if you use canned chicken/turkey broth, make sure it's the low sodium variety, so you aren't accidentally adding more salt while refrigerating and reheating.



Step 6. Cover the pan with a lid or piece of aluminum foil and refrigerate.
1638208634279-png.626820


Those photos of turkey are making me hungry now. :teeth:

.
 
I can see preparing the sides ahead of time, but for me, the turkey being cooked the day of and "presented" is an important part of the festivities. But I'm not a big fan of leftover reheated turkey in the first place. So much better right after it has come out of the oven.,

Yeah, if I only had a small oven, I'd also pick traditional sides that could be done ahead and still do the turkey on the day b/c once it's in, there's almost no work and you can socialize, whereas sides tend to have the constant work...

If I had a big family and small kitchen at Christmas, I'd do 2 pans of lasagna (1 big normal cheese and 1 allergy veg, since we have those, there) - both make ahead, a crockpot of baby meatballs - again, make ahead, green salad, and macedonia (which is make ahead and right out of the fridge) and some bread and olive oil and call it a day...
 
I can see preparing the sides ahead of time, but for me, the turkey being cooked the day of and "presented" is an important part of the festivities. But I'm not a big fan of leftover reheated turkey in the first place. So much better right after it has come out of the oven.,
All well and good unless you work retail and have to work until midnight the night before and be there at 4 am for Black Friday. My host cooked the turkey the Thursday prior, sliced it up and froze it. We tossed it in the oven with some other stuff to warm up. With juices and the gravy, it was just fine.
 
We have cooked a turkey many times over the years the day before we ate it. DH has always carved the bird in the kitchen and "presented" the slices and legs on my fine china platter. :)
 
I smoked our TG turkey the day prior then warmed it in the oven the day of. I brine so the next day when re-heated it stays moist. And don't heat it up past 140ish and do so on a low temperature (250-275).
 












Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE







New Posts



DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top