Thanks. I had reserved a TH at WH, then a friend offered a timeshare to us for only $220 for the week (paying $728 for 8 nights at WH). So there was my dilemma. We decided to stay with WH for the reasons you mentioned - at the vistana, its a timeshare and not sure what you'd get. Plus I too read mixed reviews on it. At least at WH, I rented directly thru the owner, she sent me tons of pictures and a couple others on the board stayed there as well and told me how nice it was. And the big seller -- it has the private splash pool, which we wouldnt have at the Vistana. Thank you for your input!