It has been so great reading about POFQ. We are staying there this December and this is making me SO extra-excited (if that is possible?)!
Honestly, that shrimp po' boy looks so good, that is one I can't wait to try. And we've been going back and forth about boatwrights, because, as you noted, it doesn't have the best rep on the boards. Still, it's going to be SO close and I don't think I'd ever go out of my way to eat there so a part of me wants to try it on this trip. I think your review just may be the tipping point in deciding to go for it.
Thanks again for all the great photos and reviews!