Rejected Offers Thread

[HyperspaceMountainPilot]

PVB - Aug UY - 220points $160 offer, $169 asking 5/17/24

While I do NOT think $169 is a reasonable price to pay for PVB, my guess is that they will get it (unless it’s stripped all the way to 2026) with the recent ROFR frenzy. I didn’t want to accept a $135 counter last winter so I’m definitely not in the market for Poly resale now, but if I was, I’d consider trying to get a transfer of PVB points to tide me over a year or two and then plan to buy discount resale or under $200 direct in 2026.

 

[Kailunkat]

While I do NOT think $169 is a reasonable price to pay for PVB, my guess is that they will get it (unless it’s stripped all the way to 2026) with the recent ROFR frenzy. I didn’t want to accept a $135 counter last winter so I’m definitely not in the market for Poly resale now, but if I was, I’d consider trying to get a transfer of PVB points to tide me over a year or two and then plan to buy discount resale or under $200 direct in 2026.

I'm with you - but it's been a hot minute since any contracts with 2024 points (let alone banked) have hit market. Pretty much everything is 2025 or stripped.

The listing for $169 did sell - I believe for asking (I was given the opportunity to increase bid to $170 but declined)

 

[HyperspaceMountainPilot]

I'm with you - but it's been a hot minute since any contracts with 2024 points (let alone banked) have hit market. Pretty much everything is 2025 or stripped.

The listing for $169 did sell - I believe for asking (I was given the opportunity to increase bid to $170 but declined)

Wow, what an “opportunity.”

I don’t judge anybody who wants to throw down $200 for Poly resale, I paid direct for AUL so I’m the last to throw stones. I just think if you’re already going to spend $170 (for non-loaded contracts), it’s worth buying direct or waiting a year for resale.